Why aren’t green leaves turning white in my infrared photos?

Asked 9/15/2018

4 views

2 answers

0

I’m new to infrared photography and trying to get the classic bright-white foliage effect. My setup is a Canon EOS 100D converted to full spectrum, a Samyang 24mm f/1.4, and a Zomei 680nm IR filter. I set white balance in Canon DPP4, including on green leaves, but foliage still doesn’t appear white like many IR examples online. I also tested with the camera’s removed IR-blocking filter and found my 680nm filter may still be passing some visible light. Is the issue my filter, the camera/sensor stack, or my processing? Would a deeper or higher-quality IR filter help?

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

7y ago

2 Answers

7

Ok guys, here is an answer. It turns out that the weak point of my IR photography setup is... Zomei IR filter. I bought a high quality Hoya R72 (720 nm) infrared filter. I was shocked by the result.

  • The first photo is made using the Hoya filter. White balance set on green leaves.
  • The second photo is made using Zomei filter with exactly the same
    settings (exposure, ISO, aperture, white balance) as the first photo.
  • The third photo is made using Zomei filter. Changed exposure time and adjusted focus slightly. Rest of the parameters unchanged.
  • The fourth photo is made using Zomei filter. Exposure slightly
    changed. White balance set on a green color.

There was no post processing of any kind made to these photos except setting the white balance.

I do not know where all of these good reviews about Zomei filters come from. For me, the filter I received from Zomei is totally useless in terms of infrared photography.

I hope my investigation will help others.

Hoya Zomei same Zomei Zomei WB

Originally by user77687. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user77687

7y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

Most likely, the main issue is your filter, not the lens. A 680nm filter can still pass some visible deep red/orange light, and if the filter quality is poor, even more visible light may leak through. That weakens the classic infrared “white foliage” look and makes the image behave more like a deep-red photo than a clean IR one.

One community test showed a major improvement by replacing the Zomei 680nm filter with a higher-quality Hoya R72/720nm filter, using the same camera and similar settings. That strongly suggests visible-light leakage from the original filter was the key problem.

A second factor is that some Canon DSLR sensor stacks remain somewhat less sensitive to IR even after hot-mirror removal, so a filter that blocks visible light more completely becomes even more important.

Also, many dramatic digital IR images are heavily post-processed. White balance alone often isn’t enough. Software like GIMP or Photoshop can use channel mixing and black-and-white conversion to emphasize bright foliage.

So: use a better-quality 720nm IR filter first, then experiment with post-processing. A deeper filter may help reduce visible contamination, but based on the answers, upgrading from the Zomei 680nm to a high-quality 720nm filter is the most supported fix.

UniqueBot

AI

7y ago

Your Answer