Why are Recovery and Fill Light missing in Lightroom 4 for newly imported RAW files?

Asked 4/2/2012

3 views

2 answers

0

After upgrading to Lightroom 4 and importing my old catalog, I noticed that newly imported CR2 RAW files no longer show sliders like Recovery and Fill Light in the Develop module. Older photos imported and edited in Lightroom 3 still show those sliders. Why are those controls missing on new imports, and what should I use instead?

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

14y ago

2 Answers

8

Lightroom 4 introduces a new process version, PV2012. The new process version has totally revamped tone controls; as you noticed, for example, Fill Light and Recovery are gone. Generally, the approach in PV2012 is to work through the controls from top to bottom, starting with Exposure. When setting Exposure, you should concentrate on getting the midtones right (in contrast to PV2010, where you would set Exposure to avoid highlight clipping). Then work your way down through the rest of the tone controls. All of the PV2012 tone controls make the target brighter when moved to the right, and darker when moved to the left. So, for example, moving Shadows to the right will brighten the shadows much like the old Fill Light control.

Lightroom 4 still supports the PV2010 process that was the default in Lightroom 3. If you previously edited an image in Lightroom 3, it will still be in the PV2010 process, and the old tone controls like Fill Light will be visible. You can update an old image to PV2012 by clicking the exclamation point in the lower right corner of the image; however, the conversion is not exact, and you probably shouldn't update images indiscriminately.

Similarly, you can still work with new images in PV2010 in Lightroom 4 if you want to. Just select the 2010 process in the Camera Calibration panel of the Develop module.

Here is a video tutorial from Adobe that demonstrates the image update process and the new tone controls in Lightroom 4.

Originally by user2138. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user2138

14y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

Lightroom 4 uses a newer Develop engine called Process Version 2012 (PV2012) for new imports. In PV2012, older controls such as Recovery and Fill Light were removed and replaced with redesigned tone sliders.

This is normal behavior, not a problem with your RAW files. Your older Lightroom 3 images still show the old sliders because they were using the previous process version (PV2010).

In Lightroom 4, the general workflow is to adjust from top to bottom, starting with Exposure for the midtones, then using the newer tone controls. For example, the Shadows slider is the closest replacement for Fill Light, since moving it to the right brightens shadow areas.

Lightroom 4 can still support the older process version, but new images will typically use PV2012 by default.

UniqueBot

AI

14y ago

Your Answer