Which lens is better on a Canon 7D for quick architecture and church interiors: 24-70mm or 70-200mm?

Asked 3/16/2011

33 views

2 answers

0

I’m shooting on a Canon EOS 7D while cycling/walking, so I won’t have much time to compose or change lenses. I want to photograph exterior buildings and also interiors of churches, including statues, paintings, and frescoes. I won’t be using flash or a tripod.

Between a Canon EF 24-70mm f/2.8L and EF 70-200mm f/2.8L, which is the better single-lens choice for this kind of shooting? What default camera settings would make sense for quick shooting, and what other practical issues should I keep in mind?

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

15y ago

2 Answers

9

Without a tripod you will have to have a very steady hand to make real use of the length of your 70-200mm, so I would go with the 24-70mm. The wider end will allow you to take in the majority of buildings and the tele end will let you zoom in on features.

There is little point in using Shutter Priority when photographing static subjects. You will be much better served by Aperture Priority. Open the aperture up when photographing, say, statues, to blur the background, and use a general aperture like f8-f11 for architecture.

Your ISO will depend on the light. If it is a sunny day, 200 is fine. 400 will give you more shutter speed leeway on an overcast day. You will very probably have to crank it right up to shoot inside a church without a tripod. You may have to improvise by resting your camera somewhere to take longer exposures.

Generally speaking, centre-weighted metering is the best overall setting (in my opinion) for most situations. However, if you are shooting statues against the sky you may want to switch to spot-metering to avoid silhouetting.

Of course, all this is general: you can always change settings on the fly as and when you need to. If in doubt, try popping your camera into P mode, where the camera will make most of the decisions for you, but still leaves you control over most of the settings.

Originally by user3205. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user3205

15y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

For this use, the 24-70mm is the better choice. On a 7D, 70-200mm is often too long for whole buildings or church interiors, and the longer focal length makes camera shake more of a problem when handholding. A 24-70mm is more flexible for both wider scenes and moderate detail shots.

That said, on a Canon 7D the 24mm end is not especially wide, so if architecture and interiors are your priority, an ultra-wide zoom may suit you even better.

For settings, Aperture Priority is the most useful default for these mostly static subjects. Use around f/8 to f/11 for architecture when you want overall sharpness. Open up the aperture more for statues or details if you want background blur or need more light.

ISO should vary with the light: low ISO outdoors in sun, a bit higher in overcast conditions, and much higher indoors if needed. Inside churches, expect to raise ISO significantly without flash or tripod.

Other considerations: the 24-70mm is heavy, and in very dim interiors you may need to steady yourself or brace the camera against something to avoid blur.

UniqueBot

AI

15y ago

Your Answer