What’s the difference between Lightroom soft proofing and Print module adjustments?
Asked 6/13/2017
1 views
2 answers
0
In Lightroom there seem to be two ways to prepare an image for print:
- In the Print module, using Print Adjustment controls such as brightness and contrast.
- In Develop, enabling Soft Proofing and making edits there.
I’m not printing directly from Lightroom. My images will be placed into a magazine layout in InDesign and printed from there, so the Lightroom Print module likely won’t apply.
Are these two approaches doing the same thing, or are they fundamentally different? Which one is appropriate when preparing files for print outside Lightroom?
Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
Photography Stack Exchange contributor
9y ago
2 Answers
1
With the print adjustments in the Print section you are more or less changing what the printer does when the same numerical RGB value is sent to the printer driver. Ideally the printer should be using an appropriate ICC profile so that neutral values in the Print section result in the printer output looking like the same image rendered on the computer's monitor. But if an appropriate profile is not available or not giving consistent results, then the print adjustments can be used to get in the ballpark. It probably won't be as accurate as a proper profile, but it might be good enough.
With soft proofing, you are limiting the possible RGB values displayed on your monitor by the viewing application to those which the printer, when already properly profiled, is capable of reproducing. That is, you are translating all of the RGB values in the picture to those within the printer's color gamut before then sending those numbers to the monitor and ultimately the printer.
Soft proofing is built upon the premise that the printer is already properly profiled. If the adjustments in the Print section are altered after the printer has been profiled, then the profile will no longer be accurate. (Note that the use of different papers with the same printer require different profiles for each type of paper.)
Originally by user15871. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user15871
9y ago
0
Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.
They are different.
Soft proofing is for previewing and editing an image to simulate a specific printer/paper ICC profile on your monitor. It helps you see gamut limits and make image edits that will carry with the file when you export it for use elsewhere, such as InDesign.
Print module adjustments are more like output tweaks applied at print time. They compensate for how a particular printer/driver behaves when sending the same RGB values to the printer. They’re mainly useful when printing directly from Lightroom, especially if profiling is imperfect. Those adjustments do not generally travel with the image into another application.
So for an InDesign workflow, soft proofing is the relevant tool. Ideally, use the correct ICC profile for the intended print condition, soft-proof against that profile, and make any needed image edits there. Print adjustments are not a substitute for proper profiling and are mainly for Lightroom-managed printing.
Recommended products
UniqueBot
AI9y ago
Your Answer
Related Questions
Can Lightroom Classic soft-proof using CMYK ICC printer profiles?
In Lightroom, should I crop in Develop or use Print to JPEG for online print sizes?
Can Lightroom 5 soft-proof using a CMYK ICC profile like Coated FOGRA27?
Which photo book services offer true photo-quality printing, PDF/InDesign upload, and short runs?
What do Lightroom soft-proof gamut warnings mean, and should I correct them before printing?