What type of camera and lens are good for beginner astrophotography?
Asked 12/7/2013
71 views
2 answers
0
I’m getting back into photography after many years away and want to focus on astrophotography. I may also want to use the camera for regular photography, so I’m trying to understand what type of camera is best.
Should I be looking at a full-frame DSLR or a dedicated cooled CCD/monochrome astronomy camera? What are the tradeoffs for a beginner, and what kind of lens or optical setup makes sense for astrophotography?
Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
Photography Stack Exchange contributor
12y ago
2 Answers
2
When it comes to astrophotography, assuming that is your primary focus, you really have two options: A full-frame DSLR, or a dedicated monochrome CCD camera. A dedicated CCD camera will generally take much better photos, and give you far more control, for astrophotography alone (particularly deep sky, but with focal reducers a short focal length telescope can become a pretty nice wide field lens.)
If you also want to take regular photos, and still want the best camera you can get for astrophotography, then you should look at a full frame DSLR. In particular, the Canon EOS 6D. The 6D is a very reasonably priced full frame camera (in the US, it currently sells for around $1400), but it also has some of the cleanest high ISO noise to be found outside of the Canon EOS 1D X (which sells for almost $7000!)
The very, very clean, low level of high ISO noise on the 6D, combined with its relatively large pixels, make it an ideal astrophotography camera. It costs about the same as a dedicated high quality astrophotography CDD, but is far more versatile as it is a regular old DSLR as well.
If you need a more capable camera that still offers low noise at high ISO, and you have more money to spend, the Canon EOS 5D III is probably one of the most versatile cameras on the market. Similarly, the Nikon D800E, which is priced similarly to the 5D III, offers more resolution and finer detail, which can be a boon for astrophotography. Neither the D800 nor the 5D III have quite the level of quality the 6D does when it comes to high ISO performance...the 6D is VERY usable up to ISO 3200, and still quite usable at ISO 6400 (where as by ISO 6400 the 5D III will start eating up higher magnitude stars.)
If I had to recommend the single best device for photography+astrophotography, it would be the 6D. Great price, very versatile camera, excellent IQ at high ISO...the only way to do better (at the time of this writing) is buy a dedicated telescope CCD camera.
Historically, astrophotography before the digital era could be done on a variety of film cameras. The use of a medium format film camera was not a necessity, although you certainly had a larger frame which could be useful. Doing astrophotography with film these days is probably more difficult than with digital, and certainly more costly. You have to deal with reciprocity failure, so calculating how long you need to expose to get the exposure you want can become a little difficult for longer exposures (i.e. exposures on a tracking mount.) You also incur the cost of buying the film and having it developed, where as with digital you can do it all yourself with your own personal computer and some tools like Adobe Lightroom, Adobe Photoshop, Deep Sky Stacker, Registax, etc.
Originally by user124. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user124
12y ago
0
Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.
For astrophotography, the two main paths are:
-
Full-frame DSLR: Best if you want one camera for both night sky and everyday photography. A full-frame body is a common recommendation because of good high-ISO performance and lower noise. The Canon EOS 6D was specifically recommended in the replies as a strong astrophotography-friendly DSLR.
-
Dedicated cooled CCD/monochrome astronomy camera: Best if astrophotography is your only goal, especially deep-sky imaging. These cameras generally offer more control and better results, but they usually require a computer, external power, and a telescope or astro imaging setup. They are less convenient for normal photography.
For lenses/optics, astrophotography often uses either a wide lens for sky scenes or a short-focal-length telescope for deep sky; a focal reducer can help create a wider field of view.
So, for a beginner returning to photography: choose a full-frame DSLR if you want versatility, and choose a cooled CCD/mono astro camera if you want a dedicated night-sky system.
Recommended products
UniqueBot
AI12y ago
Your Answer
Related Questions
What kind of hydrogen-alpha filter is needed for safe solar photography, and can I use a regular astronomy H-alpha filter?
What makes a lens a macro lens, and what are the alternatives for close-up photography?
What’s the best budget way to start black-and-white photography: digital RAW conversion or black-and-white film?
Why don’t high-end DSLR cameras use cooled image sensors to reduce noise?
Best beginner camera setup for bird photography on a $500–$1,000 budget