What should I choose when Photoshop warns that an embedded color profile doesn’t match my working RGB space?

Asked 9/21/2017

4 views

2 answers

0

When I open RAW files in Photoshop, I get a color profile mismatch warning like this:

  • Embedded: Adobe RGB (1998)
  • Working: Monitor RGB / sRGB IEC61966-2.1

Photoshop asks whether to:

  • use the embedded profile,
  • convert the document to the working space, or
  • discard the embedded profile.

What does each option actually do, and which choice is normally best for editing and final printing? I also see sRGB and Adobe RGB settings in my Nikon camera. Which should I use for the best print results, and how can I set Photoshop/ACR so this warning doesn’t appear every time I open a RAW file?

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

8y ago

2 Answers

1

When you open a raw file in PS, it first gets presented in ACR. There, you can set the colour space you want to assign to the demosaiced image. Adobe RGB is a good default, you might think about changing it to ProPhoto, as long as you work in 16 bit mode in PS. You can also select sRGB there already.

sRGB is the smallest of the three, followed by Adobe and ProPhoto. Working in a wider color space means you have more extreme colours available. But for final output, you may have to convert it down, as most output devices can't cope with those wide spaces! For web use, sRGB is generally still recommended, as a common denominator.

When you then continue to PS, where your working space is evidently configured to be sRGB, you can either

  • convert the image down to the working space.

    This would be a suboptimal solution. If you want to restrict your image to sRGB in edit, do so already in ACR, as stated before.

  • use the embedded space.

    This in effect means to ignore the default of PS and switch the working space to Adobe RGB for this image.

  • discard (ignore) the embedded profile.

    This is the worst, and probably wrong option. Your image will be represented with wrong colours, not at all like you painstakingly finetuned it in ACR!

So, in summary, work in the same color space you produced from ACR, and mind the final space when you save as eg. JPEG.

For printing, the final step is usually soft-proofing, where you display the image converted to the color profile of your printer and adjust it so it looks as good as possible under its restrictions.

Originally by user32110. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user32110

8y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

For RAW files, the camera’s sRGB/Adobe RGB setting is not very important to the actual RAW data; the key choice is the color space you set in Adobe Camera Raw before opening into Photoshop.

What the Photoshop options mean:

  • "Use embedded profile": keep the file in its current color space. Usually the safest choice if you want to preserve the image appearance.
  • "Convert to working space": remaps colors into your Photoshop working space. Fine if that’s your intended workflow, but converting from a wider space to a smaller one can reduce available colors.
  • "Discard profile": removes color management. Usually not recommended.

Common workflow:

  • Edit in a wider-gamut space such as Adobe RGB, or ProPhoto RGB if working in 16-bit.
  • Convert later for the final output device.
  • For web output, sRGB is generally recommended.

For printing, a wider space can retain more saturated colors during editing, but final output often still needs conversion to the printer/output profile.

To stop the warning, make your ACR output space and Photoshop working space match, or change Photoshop’s color management policies/profile mismatch warnings in Color Settings.

UniqueBot

AI

8y ago

Your Answer