What physically distinguishes a macro lens from a regular lens?
Asked 2/4/2013
5 views
2 answers
0
I know a regular lens can be made to focus closer by moving it farther from the sensor, for example with extension tubes. So is a macro lens mainly just a lens that allows more extension, or are there other physical/design differences between a macro lens and a normal prime or zoom?
I'm especially asking about the structural and optical differences that let a macro lens reach very close focus and 1:1 magnification.
Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
Photography Stack Exchange contributor
13y ago
2 Answers
13
A simple lens (like the lens in a pair of glasses) forms an image at a distance of f behind the lens for an object at infinity (where f is the focal length). The same lens will form an image at 2f behind the lens for an object 2f in front of the lens. This will achieve 1:1 magnification, i.e. the definition of macro. Thus any single element lens is a macro lens when mounted in a tube 2f from the sensor.
In a multi-element lens (i.e. a camera lens) the lens forms a macro image 2f behind the rear principal plane for an object 2f in front of the front principal plane. The minimum focus distance of a "regular" lens can be increased by moving it further from the sensor, using extension tubes. Thus it's tempting to say any lens is a macro lens when mounted the correct distance from the sensor (and thus there's no difference between a macro lens and "regular" lens, other than the length of tube connecting it to the camera).
However the front principal plane can be inside the lens, so for some lenses the required 2f distance from the front principal plane can end up being a point inside the lens - which is something of a problem! So a macro lens is just a regular lens with the front principal plane within 2f from the front of the lens and rear principal plane 2f - ffd from the rear of the lens (where ffd is the flange focal distance).
The position of the principal planes in a multi element lens are highly influenced by the distribution of positive and negative elements in the lens. A retro-focus design, commonly used by wide angle lenses, pushes the principal planes backward, whereas a telephoto design pushes them forwards. This is the reason you tend to see many more telephoto macro lenses than wideangle macros.
In addition to the position of the principal planes, macro lenses are usually optimised to have a flat field i.e. the focussed image is planar as opposed to slightly curved. This is not a requirement for a lens to be a macro, but a useful feature of lenses used to photograph flat objects at close distances, e.g. to copy documents.
Originally by user1375. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user1375
13y ago
0
Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.
A macro lens is not defined by a completely different kind of optics so much as by how the lens is designed to work at very close focus.
In basic optics, any lens can reach higher magnification if you move it farther from the sensor; extension tubes do exactly that. At 1:1 magnification, the image distance is about 2× the focal length from the lens’s principal plane. So in that sense, many “regular” lenses can be used for macro with enough extension.
What makes a dedicated macro lens different is that it is built to provide that close-focus extension internally and in a usable way. Mechanically, this often means a much larger focusing travel and more barrel extension, which affects the size and construction of the lens. That’s one reason some macro lenses have built-in hoods or long barrel designs: the lens needs room to extend while still being practical.
So the key physical differences are mainly the focusing/helicoid/barrel design and the amount of extension the lens is designed to accommodate. The provided answers do not point to a fundamentally unique lens type; rather, macro lenses are regular camera lenses specifically engineered to focus much closer and reach life-size magnification without accessories.
Recommended products
UniqueBot
AI13y ago
Your Answer
Related Questions
Diopter vs extension tube for close-up photography
How do extension tubes affect a lens’s maximum magnification?
Does crop factor change true macro magnification like 1:1?
How can I increase magnification when my camera-to-subject distance is fixed?
Why do extension tubes reduce maximum focus distance and enable closer focusing?