What causes bright streaks or flare along specific axes around lights?

Asked 7/24/2016

2 views

2 answers

0

When photographing very bright light sources, I sometimes see star-like streaks or flare aligned along particular directions rather than a uniform glow. In telescopes, diffraction spikes can come from the secondary mirror supports, but what causes similar axis-aligned streaks in camera lenses? Can this be caused by the lens, dirt/smudges, or the sensor?

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

10y ago

2 Answers

8

What causes lens flare along specific axes?

This answer assumes the 1st and 3rd images are caused by the same phenomenon, and image 2 is caused by something different.

Image #2

To my eyes, this flare appears to be caused by a smudged front element. This can easily happen when one attempts to wipe the element clean, but doesn't get all of the (presumably) finger oils. The last swipe with the lens cloth went from upper right to lower left (viewed from behind the camera), thus generating the perpendicular flare.

See the following questions for similar effects (and answers):

Images #1 and #3

As you noted in your question, diffraction spikes occur when light passes a straight edge, resulting in the light spreading out perpendicular the edge. In the "Diffraction spikes due to non-circular aperture" section of the Wikipedia article on diffraction spikes, you see that a square iris aperture with straight-edged bladed causes a 4-pointed star.

However, a diamond- or lozenge-shaped 4-bladed iris will produce an X-pattern. It's still 4-pointed, but the points aren't all 90° from each other. Let me demonstrate using my rudimentary ImageMagick skills.

First, let's create our aperture, a diamond pattern (Figure 1):

convert -size 1000x1000 xc:black -fill white -draw \
    "polygon 500,400 673,500 500,600 327,500" 01-aperture.png

Figure 1: The diamond aperture
Figure 1: The horizontal diamond-shaped aperture (01-aperture.png)

A point source of light traveling through the aperture creates the X-shaped diffraction pattern in Figure 2. A Gaussian filter is applied to the diamond aperture as a windowing function, then passing through a Fast Fourier Transform (FFT), followed by another Gaussian filter after the transform to smooth out some of the intensity peaks of the star.

convert 01-aperture.png -morphology Convolve Gaussian:1x1 \
    -fft +delete -auto-level -evaluate log 100 \
    -morphology Convolve Gaussian:3x3 -auto-level -evaluate log 10 \
    02-fft.png

Figure 2: 4-pointed X-pattern from a point source light through a diamond aperture
Figure 2: 4-pointed X-pattern from a point source light through a diamond aperture (02-fft.png)

A diamond shaped aperture? Really?

Indeed. Several camcorder models had a diamond-shaped aperture. This is desirable because it is mechanically much simpler than a typical N-bladed iris aperture with N rotating iris blades. All that's needed is two V-notched blades opposing each other, and moving linearly towards or away from each other to close or open the aperture.

This arrangement also explains why X-pattern diffraction in camcorders is always perfectly oriented. In a lens with an iris aperture, such as in almost all modern photographic lenses, as the iris blades collectively rotate to close the aperture, the created N-gon aperture shape rotates. Thus the orientation of the diffracted star pattern in photographic lenses is dependent upon the aperture value setting. But in the camcorder diamond aperture, there is no rotation, so the X-pattern is always oriented the same way.

I can't find concrete details about the Canon Vixia HF R400's aperture blades, other than according to CNet's product review, its "Lens Aperture" is f/1.8–4.5. This is probably just the physical aperture range, as it also has built-in ND grad filters to further control light entry.

A review of the prosumer Panasonic AG-HMC40 1/4″ 3-CMOS HD camcorder shows that camera's diamond-shaped aperture in closeup:

enter image description here
Diamond-shaped aperture of the Panasonic AG-HMC40 camcorder. Retrieved from Provideocoalition.com under fair use for educational purposes

Originally by user11924. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user11924

10y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

Axis-aligned streaks around bright lights can come from a few different causes.

Most commonly, a directional smudge on the front element can do this. Finger oils or a wipe mark can scatter light strongly in one direction, producing a streak perpendicular to the smear. This often looks like a single strong flare axis rather than a symmetrical star.

They can also be diffraction effects from something in the optical path: dust, a hair, mild imperfections, or other structures inside the lens. The number and orientation of the streaks can hint at what caused them.

A deliberate optical accessory such as a star filter can create similar controlled streaks.

In some cases the sensor can be involved. If the streaking lines up with sensor rows or columns, blooming is another possibility, especially with very bright sources. But if the streaks are at unusual diagonal angles, that is less likely to be sensor blooming.

So yes: similar-looking streaks can come from the lens surface, contamination, internal optical elements, added filters, or sometimes the sensor.

UniqueBot

AI

10y ago

Your Answer