What caused the diffuse bright patches in the black sky of some Apollo moon photos?

Asked 8/8/2016

2 views

2 answers

0

Some Apollo lunar-surface photos show a broad, faint bright patch in the otherwise black sky when the image is brightened heavily. What is the most likely cause of this effect in photos such as Apollo 14 AS14-64-9089 and Apollo 11 AS11-40-5868?

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

9y ago

2 Answers

11

It looks like lens flare. It is an internal reflection inside the lens. It is caused by off axis light allowed to fall on the front surface if the lens from outside the field of view.

For an example of such flare when the exposure is brightened please see: Can you photograph the milky way with a full moon out?

It might also be sunlight reflecting off dust that has been kicked up by the astronaut. In the moon's gravity field that is only 1/6 as strong as that of the Earth's the same amount of force would cause the dust to go 6x higher before falling back to the surface and it would also take 6x as long for such dust to settle as it would in a vacuum under Earth's gravity. There is also no atmosphere and thus no wind to disperse the dust.

It might be possible that dust could be electrostatically stuck to the front of the lens in some of the photos taken on the surface of the moon. In the case of the Apollo 11 photo of Buzz Aldrin descending the ladder of the LEM the absence of such a smudge in photos taken subsequently argues strongly against that theory. The Apollo 11 mission only included a single EVA, so all photos of Aldrin on the Moon's surface were necessarily taken after the photo of him coming down the ladder of the LEM.

This image was 34 frames later from the same film magazine on the same camera as the shot of Buzz descending the ladder:
enter image description here
Notice that there is no evidence of dust on the lens. If one examines all of the images from that magazine it quickly becomes apparent that the angle of the sun to the camera and whether the camera is in the shade of the LEM or not are the most determining factors regarding which images demonstrate the effect and which ones don't.

Likewise, if one examines all of the images in sequence from film magazine LL on the Apollo 14 mission it becomes abundantly clear that lens flare is the main culprit.

Originally by user15871. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user15871

9y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

The most likely cause is lens flare or other internal reflections in the camera/lens system from very bright off-axis sunlight. Even if the Sun is outside the frame, light can still strike the front of the lens or other optical surfaces and create a soft, diffuse bright area that becomes obvious when contrast and brightness are boosted.

That explanation fits Apollo photography well: similar Apollo images show clear flare artifacts, and NASA has identified comparable bright patches in other mission photos as flare caused by sunlight reflecting in the window/lens system.

A secondary possibility mentioned is dust very near or on the lens, since lunar dust was highly adhesive and electrostatically clingy. However, based on the examples and comparisons discussed, lens flare/internal reflection is the stronger explanation for these sky glows.

UniqueBot

AI

9y ago

Your Answer