What are the trade-offs of using Nikon DX lenses on an FX camera in DX crop mode?

Asked 1/21/2014

1 views

2 answers

0

I currently shoot with a Nikon D90 and am considering upgrading to an FX body. I understand that FX sensors generally offer better dynamic range, high-ISO performance, and shallower depth of field than DX sensors. If I mount DX lenses on an FX camera and use DX crop mode, do I still get the FX camera’s image-quality benefits, or am I effectively back to DX performance? What compromises should I expect?

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

12y ago

2 Answers

5

DX lenses project a smaller image circle than FX lenses, smaller than an FX sensor. DX mode allows you to use an area the size of a DX sensor in the center of your FX sensor so the DX lens image circle will cover this area. Since each photosite in this area is still its full FX size, you will retain all the ISO and dynamic range capabilities of an FX sensor. However, since you are only using about an area about 45% of the full FX sensor, you will lose about 55% of your megapixels. This means a 36MP FX camera will produce 16.2MP images in DX mode, and a 24MP FX camera will produce 10.5MP images in DX mode. In addition, in DX mode, you will experience the same crop factor effect on your focal length. This means a 35mm FX lens on an FX body will give the angle of view expected, but a 35mm DX lens on a FX body will give an angle of view approximately like that of a 50mm FX lens on an FX body, just as that lens would do on an DX body.

If you have a large investment in DX lenses, DX mode can be a reasonable bridge, but you will not be using about half of your very expensive pixels, so if you have fully committed to moving from DX to FX, you should seriously consider selling your DX and lenses and acquiring FX lenses to take full advantage of your sensor.

Originally by user25468. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user25468

12y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

Using a DX lens on an FX Nikon body in DX crop mode uses only the center portion of the FX sensor, because DX lenses project a smaller image circle.

Main compromises:

  • Much lower resolution: you only use about 45% of the full FX sensor area, so you lose roughly 55% of the megapixels.
  • DX field of view: the camera behaves like a crop-sensor body in terms of angle of view.
  • Less depth-of-field advantage: the shallower-DoF benefit of FX is essentially lost when shooting in DX crop mode.

As for high ISO and dynamic range:

  • Per pixel, the used sensor area still has the FX sensor’s pixel quality, so those characteristics remain.
  • But at a given final print size, you may not see the full FX advantage, because you have fewer total pixels and less room for downscaling.

So, DX crop mode on an FX body does preserve much of the sensor’s per-pixel quality, but in practical use you give up resolution, full-frame angle of view, and most of the depth-of-field benefit that make FX attractive in the first place.

UniqueBot

AI

12y ago

Your Answer