Should Tamron VC be turned off for long exposures on a tripod?

Asked 9/18/2017

2 views

2 answers

0

I'm shooting long exposures with a Canon EOS 1300D and a Tamron 18-200mm Di II VC lens. Using a sturdy tripod, 2-second timer, ISO 100, f/29, and a 30-second exposure, I was getting blurred images even indoors with no wind. After testing, I found the blur only happens when the lens's VC (vibration compensation/image stabilization) is turned on. With VC off, the image is sharp. Is this normal behavior for Tamron VC, or does it suggest the stabilization system is faulty?

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

8y ago

2 Answers

6

It looks like movement (primarily vertical) during the exposure. I understand you think the tripod was steady, but I think the parallel doubled mountain range and background seems to indicate that during the exposure the camera moved.

EDIT: Given the updated question and example, since right now this is the upvoted, wanted to clarify since it appears to have a specific cause not just vibration.

It appears the VC is not maintaining control during the entire exposure. My GUESS is that it's timing out in some fashion and re-centering; it might also be defective. Lens based optical vibration reduction works by shifting one or more lens elements to track (or more precisely track opposite) of vibration. The effect means the field of view is shifted during exposure, ideally to keep it in one place. It is possible that it is timing out, and re-centering back to some neutral position. It is possible it is defective and "flops" in some fashion after a given time. Testing a different VC lens might tell you if this is a "feature". All that said, most vendors recommend vibration control be turned off when locked down on a tripod; a few lenses may have a "tripod mode". If it is working at more typical stabilization shutter speeds (say 1/30th), it is likely not worth pursuing.

An interesting way to tell how image stabilization interacts with long exposure is to get a dark night and lock down on a tripod and shoot a bright star for a long exposure (adjust ISO as needed to get a dark sky and thin line). Ideally you get a perfectly straight line. Rotate the camera 90 degrees and shoot again; still should be a straight line. Both regular vibration (e.g. wind) and any optical stabilization impacts can be seen in that, effectively graphed over time, and the 90 degree flip will tell you if the stabilization is different in different orientations (note some lenses have a "mode" for active or normal or similar that can affect this also). This will let you see, for example, if it times out at 10 seconds or something consistent, with a sudden movement (my guess), or if it is just jittery. Reading the manual (lens or camera) to see if there's any comment on timeout may help also.

Originally by user28109. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user28109

8y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

Yes—this can be normal. Lens stabilization systems like Tamron VC are generally meant for handheld shooting, not for long exposures on a tripod. On a tripod, VC may try to correct movement that isn’t there, or it can shift/re-center during the exposure, causing blur or a doubled image.

Several users report that Tamron VC can also move the image if it hasn’t fully settled before the shot. For tripod shots, especially long exposures, the usual advice is to turn VC/IS/OS off unless the lens specifically has a tripod-aware stabilization mode.

So your test results strongly suggest the blur is caused by VC being active on the tripod, not by forgotten basics. If the lens is sharp with VC off, that points to expected stabilizer behavior rather than a general camera problem. If you ever see the same issue while shooting handheld at normal shutter speeds, then it could indicate a fault.

UniqueBot

AI

8y ago

Your Answer