Should I buy a second RT flash or a dedicated RT transmitter for my Canon 600EX II-RT?
Asked 2/13/2018
5 views
2 answers
0
I’m new to flash and need to use a Canon Speedlite 600EX II-RT off-camera on a stand for an indoor event. My camera is a Canon 6D Mark II.
I’m considering either:
- an RT transmitter such as the Canon ST-E3-RT or Yongnuo YN-E3-RT, or
- a second RT-compatible flash such as the Yongnuo YN600EX-RT II.
My thinking is that a second flash could sit on-camera and trigger the remote flash, while also giving me the option of using on-camera flash when needed. On the other hand, a dedicated transmitter is smaller and lighter.
Is my understanding correct that an RT flash on-camera can act as the radio master for an off-camera RT flash? In practice, when is it better to use a dedicated transmitter instead of another speedlite? Also, is Yongnuo RT gear generally compatible with Canon RT flashes?
Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
Photography Stack Exchange contributor
8y ago
2 Answers
1
I have a Canon 6D (MK1), 3 YN 600RT speelights, and the YN RT Controller. I do portraits and some event photography (birthdays, baby showers, etc.). If you are asking about how the YN equipment has performed, then I can say that it has worked wonderfully for me and my needs. The cost savings are substantial. Prior to "upgrading"/purchasing the YN RT speedlights, I had a couple of non-RT Canon 430 EX speedlights, so I am somewhat familiar with the Canon speedlight family.
If you are asking about the focus assist light, you'll have to determine how important/valuable that feature is to. I have not used it because it's too distracting. The low light autofocusing on the 6D has worked fine for me thus far. FYI - the YN RT controller is compatible with Canon RT speedlights also.
But separate from the equipment questions, I do have a concern with your overall situation. Are you being paid for this "indoor thing"? With you having never worked with flash before (on-camera or off-camera), not having time to do research, not being familiar with the equipment, preparing to spend $1000+ for Canon flash equipment, etc., all seems like a disaster in the making. If you are expecting to be paid for this event, I suggest you pass this one off to someone who knows what they are doing, and you spend some time learning about how to use the flash and practicing with family and friends before charging for your photographs. Learn about bounce flash, flash power, ambient light vs. flash light, flash synch speed, flash distance, etc. I'm not suggesting that you need to have a "PhD" in flash photography - these concepts are definitely digestible and learnable with practice, and you should be able to produce pretty good pictures fairl quickly. However, jumping into this with family or clients depending on you in your very first outing with flash is very risky. At the very least, maybe you can arrange to have a primary, experienced shooter do the event, and you can be an unpaid 2d shooter getting some practice in? Good luck to you!
EDIT: Add'l answer: Whether you need two flashes (1 on camera, 1 off camera) or 1 (on camera) really depends on what type of shooting you expect to do at this event. Pro wedding photogs sometimes use both. With the OCF option, you'll have the extra burden/work of having to move the flash/stand around all night, depending on where your subject is. This might be easier if you have an asst to move the light/stand for you. I think you could work quicker and have more flexibility if you just stayed simple and went with on-camera flash (w/some type of bounce or diffusion). In any event, the YN RT controller on your camera can control the off-camera Canon flash if you wanted to go that route.
Originally by user28422. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user28422
8y ago
0
Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.
Yes—an RT-capable speedlite on the camera can act as the radio master and trigger an off-camera RT flash, so your basic understanding is correct.
Which is better depends on how you’ll shoot:
- Second flash: better if you want the option of both on-camera flash and off-camera flash. It also gives you an extra light for future setups.
- Dedicated transmitter: better if you only need to trigger/control remote flash. It’s smaller, lighter, and less awkward on the camera, especially for long events or moving through crowds.
From the answers provided, Yongnuo RT gear is generally compatible with Canon RT flashes, and at least one user reports good real-world results using Yongnuo RT speedlites and controller with a Canon 6D.
About the AF-assist light: it may help in low light, but it’s not essential for everyone; one user found the 6D focused fine without relying on it.
So: if you value flexibility and an extra flash, the second RT flash makes sense. If you mainly want a compact trigger for off-camera use, get the transmitter.
Recommended products
UniqueBot
AI8y ago
Your Answer
Related Questions
Can a Canon Rebel XS use a 600EX-RT and ST-E3-RT with full remote TTL control?
Can a Canon 70D trigger a 600EX-RT by radio, or do I need a transmitter?
Why does the ST-E3-RT limit shutter speed on a Canon 5D Mark II with a 600EX-RT?
Can the Canon 600EX-RT control non-RT flash units by radio?
Can a Yongnuo YN-622C trigger a YN-600EX-RT II, or do I need an RT transmitter?