Should color space conversion happen before or after final resize and sharpening?
Asked 1/15/2012
7 views
2 answers
0
When exporting an image for the web or another final output, I usually do the last steps by resizing to the target dimensions and then sharpening for that final size. If I have edited in a larger color space such as ProPhoto RGB or Adobe RGB but need to export in a smaller space like sRGB, should I convert to the target color space before or after resizing and sharpening?
Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
Photography Stack Exchange contributor
14y ago
2 Answers
1
My last steps, in order, are resize, sharpen, convert color space from ProRGB to sRGB, convert to 8-bit.
The only really critical orders are sharpening after resizing and changing to 8-bit after changing the color space.
In fact, I was curious, so I just tried. One copy, I did my above steps. On the other copy, I converted color space, converted to 8-bit and then resized and sharpend. I put the images over each other and changed the blending mode to difference.
There was absolutely no pixel level difference between the two. I expect to see a few minor differences at 100% that would never show up on the print, but in the case of this one particular photo, there were absolutely no differences at all.
Originally by user7777. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user7777
14y ago
0
Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.
In practice, it usually makes little visible difference whether you convert color space before or after final resize and sharpening. Sharpening in Adobe RGB, ProPhoto RGB, or sRGB will generally produce very similar results.
The more important workflow rules are:
- resize before final output sharpening
- if reducing bit depth, convert color space before converting to 8-bit
A sensible order is:
- resize to the final output dimensions
- apply final sharpening for that size
- convert to the target color space (for example, sRGB for web)
- convert to 8-bit if needed for export
Keeping the color space conversion until the end is a common recommendation, since converting to a smaller gamut can potentially reduce some tonal or color nuance. But based on the community feedback, either order around sharpening is unlikely to create meaningful differences in most real-world images.
Recommended products
UniqueBot
AI14y ago
Your Answer
Related Questions
How can I export sRGB from Bibble 5 Lite or batch-convert ProPhoto RGB files?
Should I edit RAW photos in ProPhoto RGB or stick with sRGB for web use?
What color space does Lightroom use in the Develop module, and why export in ProPhoto or Adobe RGB?
When should I use sRGB vs a wider color space like Adobe RGB or ProPhoto RGB?
In Photoshop, is Adobe ACE more accurate than Microsoft ICM for color profile conversions?