Should a beginner shoot RAW, and is Lightroom or Aperture better on a Retina MacBook?
Asked 9/13/2012
3 views
2 answers
0
I’m starting photography as a hobby and want to know if shooting in RAW is a good choice for a beginner. I have a MacBook with a Retina display and would like a good RAW-processing program. Is Adobe Lightroom the better option, or is Apple Aperture also a solid choice for beginners and more advanced users?
Originally by user11587. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user11587
13y ago
2 Answers
2
I use Lightroom, but that is because I like the integration with other adobe products. It is really easy to open a photo in Lightroom in Photoshop from light room and then send the updated file back. I have considered switching to Aperture, but I felt like the time to move my photo library and learn a new system wasn't worth it.
That being said, from what I've read about Aperture it is a high quality application. I think the decision between the two will come down to very minor personal preferences similar to choosing Nikon or Cannon. It will come down to how you plan to use either app.
Adobe is releasing a retina update for Lightroom 4 to improve its use on the MBP Retina.
my 2cents
Originally by user21996. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user21996
13y ago
0
Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.
Yes—shooting RAW is a good choice if you want more flexibility when editing, though it does add processing work. For software, both Lightroom and Aperture are capable RAW-processing applications and both have been used by beginners and professionals.
Lightroom is often preferred if you already use other Adobe software, because its workflow integrates well with programs like Photoshop. If you’re familiar with Adobe’s interface, that can make the learning curve easier.
Aperture was also considered a strong, professional-quality option, especially for Mac users, and was seen as good value. In practice, the choice between the two is mostly about workflow and personal preference rather than one being clearly “better” for image quality.
On a Retina MacBook, either should be suitable, with support/improvements for high-resolution displays expected from the vendors.
So: as a beginner, RAW is fine, and you likely won’t go wrong with either program. Choose Lightroom if Adobe integration matters to you; choose Aperture if you prefer Apple’s ecosystem and interface.
Recommended products
UniqueBot
AI13y ago
Your Answer
Related Questions
Which Mac photo editing apps support the MacBook Pro Retina display?
Can Lightroom or other RAW converters match Nikon Capture NX color?
Lightroom vs Aperture for RAW post-processing on Mac
Do I need a Mac for Aperture, or is there a similar Windows alternative?
What is a good Lightroom workflow for processing RAW photos?