Mechanical vs electronic shutter: when should you use each?
Asked 5/12/2021
2 views
2 answers
0
My camera lets me choose between a mechanical shutter and an electronic shutter, and in casual shots I don’t see much difference. What are the practical pros and cons of each? In what situations is one better than the other, and when would you choose one over the other?
Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
Photography Stack Exchange contributor
5y ago
2 Answers
20
Fujifilm has a nice summary of the issues with each.
Electronic Shutters (ES) have some interesting characteristics due to the way the image is read out of the sensor.
Moving objects can be distorted, fluorescent/LED lights can leave light and dark bands across the frame, and ES can't usually be used with flash. On the plus side ES can have very high shutter speeds, are silent, and don't vibrate the camera.
Mechanical shutters (MS) can use flash and are better at freezing fast moving objects without distortion.
I use MS for most situations and switch to ES when I want a silent shutter or I'm doing macro work on a tripod.
Originally by user11772. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user11772
5y ago
0
Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.
Electronic shutter is useful when you need silence, very high shutter speeds, or the least possible vibration. That can make it handy for discreet shooting or some tripod/macro work.
Its downsides are mostly tied to sensor readout speed: fast-moving subjects can show rolling-shutter distortion, and some artificial lighting (especially fluorescent or LED) can cause banding. Electronic shutter also usually can’t be used with flash. On some cameras, using electronic shutter may also reduce RAW bit depth to boost frame rate, which can slightly reduce dynamic range.
Mechanical shutter is generally the safer default. It works with flash, is less prone to distortion with motion, and avoids most banding issues under problematic lights. That’s why many photographers use it for general shooting and action.
A related mode is electronic first curtain with mechanical second curtain. It can reduce vibration, but in some cases may produce unusual out-of-focus blur shapes.
In short: use mechanical shutter for most everyday, action, flash, or tricky-light situations; switch to electronic shutter when you specifically want silence, less vibration, or faster shutter speeds and can tolerate its limitations.
Recommended products
UniqueBot
AI5y ago
Your Answer
Related Questions
What’s the difference between Nikon DX and FX lenses, and when should you choose each?
Diopter vs extension tube for close-up photography
Sony α7R II shutter modes: mechanical vs electronic front-curtain vs silent—pros and cons?
Canvas or muslin vs seamless paper for studio backdrops
What camera supports are available, and when should you use a tripod, monopod, or flexible support?