Is the Pentax FluCard noticeably slower than a Class 10 SD card in a Pentax K-3?
Asked 4/7/2015
2 views
2 answers
0
I'm considering Pentax's Wi-Fi SD card because it adds basic remote control from a phone or computer, but I've seen claims that it makes the camera feel sluggish. Has anyone compared the Pentax FluCard with a typical fast Class 10 card in a Pentax K-3? For reference, I normally use SanDisk Extreme/Extreme Pro cards around 80–95 MB/s. Should I expect similar performance, or is the FluCard noticeably slower when writing bursts and clearing the buffer?
Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
Photography Stack Exchange contributor
11y ago
2 Answers
4
I have a K-3 with both the "FLUCARD PRO 16 GB O-FC1" and a "SanDisk Extreme" Class 10 80MB/s 32 GB.
The SanDisk stores images about twice as fast as my FluCard.
I've figured this with the following test:
- Erase the memory cards.
- Set the K-3 to manual exposure, 1/500th, Motor Drive H (9 shots/s).
- Hold down the shutter for as long as the camera takes pictures at high speed.
- Measure the time from pressing the shutter until the orange "saving" light goes off.
Results:
- With either card being the storage medium, I got to take 23 pictures.
- SanDisk takes about 18 seconds, FluCard takes about 38 seconds.
These results are consistent when repeated. And it makes no difference whether I place the card in slot 1 or 2.
Apart from these results, I don't have the impression that the card makes the camera "sluggish" in its general operation.
Mind you, though. I had also bought a Sony Class 10 32 GB card in 2014, supposedly even faster rated than the SanDisk. Yet, the Sony also was rather slow, within the range of the FluCard. I then found another batch of supposedly the same rated Sony card which was as fast in saving as the SanDisk. (More details in this Pentaxforums post of mine.) Meaning that at least Sony has good and bad batches of their cards without announcing it (they only print the reading speed on the label, but the critical one is the writing speed, which obviously varies drastically). Same may be true for the FluCard, i.e. there might be batches that are faster. But I doubt it unless someone claims the opposite :)
Despite the slowness, I am not much bothered by it. I just use the SanDisk in slot 1 and leave the Flucard in slot 2 for cases where I run out of memory (which is rare) or when I should need the Flucard's special features. Since even the K-3 can't write to both cards simultaneously, there is no speed advantage of using two cards anyway, i.e. even if I shoot RAW+, I still have both saved to the SanDisk card. Fills up more quickly this way, but I won't have a speed disadvantage by not using the slower second card at the same time.
Originally by user4859. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user4859
11y ago
0
Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.
Yes — based on the reported comparison, the Pentax FluCard is noticeably slower than a fast Class 10 card in a K-3.
One user tested a K-3 with both a FluCard Pro 16GB O-FC1 and a SanDisk Extreme Class 10 80MB/s card using the same burst-shooting setup. Both cards allowed 23 shots in the burst, but the time until the camera finished writing was about 18 seconds with the SanDisk versus about 38 seconds with the FluCard. That’s roughly half the write speed.
So if you’re used to SanDisk Extreme/Extreme Pro performance, the FluCard is not in the same ballpark for write speed, especially when clearing the buffer after bursts. The camera may not feel slower in every operation, but image storage is clearly slower in this comparison.
If your priority is Wi-Fi and remote control, the FluCard may still be useful. If your priority is fast burst recovery and overall write performance, a conventional fast SD card will perform better.
Recommended products
UniqueBot
AI11y ago
Your Answer
Related Questions
What SD card speed does the Canon EOS 550D / Rebel T2i actually need?
What SD card speed and type does the GoPro HD HERO2 need for 32GB recording?
Do very fast SD cards help in a camera that doesn't support UHS?
SD card has become very slow and one camera reports write errors — can it be fixed?
What SD card sizes and speed classes work with the Canon EOS 1000D?