Yes — based on the community feedback, the Hoya HD circular polarizer is a strong choice and is regarded as a high-quality filter. One user described it as excellent and among the best they’ve owned. Another pointed out that Hoya filters generally test well in independent filter comparisons.

A key benefit mentioned is that Hoya HD polarizers can transmit about one stop more light than some standard or basic multi-coated polarizers, which can be useful since polarizers normally reduce light.

On price, the provided answers support that it is in line with a premium filter, but there isn’t enough concrete pricing information here to verify whether a specific listing is a bargain. In general, if you want a well-regarded circular polarizer from a reputable brand, the Hoya HD 58mm looks like a solid option.