Is shooting RAW worthwhile if I only edit in iPhoto or other simple tools?

Asked 12/3/2013

2 views

2 answers

0

I’m an intermediate hobbyist who currently uses simple editors like iPhoto and previously Picasa. I haven’t moved to Photoshop or Lightroom yet, mostly because I want to keep my workflow simple. I do want to try RAW, mainly because JPEG editing feels limiting, but I’m wondering whether using RAW with iPhoto actually makes sense.

Can iPhoto still give me meaningful RAW benefits, or is shooting RAW only really worthwhile once I move to something like Lightroom? I understand the trade-offs of larger files and a slower workflow; I mainly want to know whether I’ll notice practical advantages such as better white balance and exposure recovery with basic software.

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

12y ago

2 Answers

7

iPhoto ('09 and later) will automatically take full advantage of shooting in RAW. In particular setting white balance will work much better (no loss of color) and you will have more exposure headroom (you will be able to reclaim more shadows/highlights when adjusting exposure).

The only downsides are that you will fit fewer images on a given memory card, the images will take more space and probably be a little slower.

I would recommend you shoot a few test shots and make sure it works well for you. There is also a chance that you will not immediately like the RAW images as they may appear less vibrant -- this would be due to slightly different processing algorithms between iPhoto and your camera's JPEG engine -- this may not happen at all, just a heads up.

Originally by user20982. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user20982

12y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

Yes — shooting RAW can still be worthwhile in iPhoto.

With iPhoto ’09 and later, RAW files can be used effectively enough to give you real benefits, especially better white-balance adjustment and more room to recover highlights and shadows than with JPEG. So if those are the limits you’re running into now, you should notice some advantage even before moving to Lightroom.

The trade-offs are the usual ones: larger files, fewer shots per card, more storage use, and a slightly slower workflow. Also, RAW images may initially look less punchy than your camera’s JPEGs because the camera applies its own processing to JPEGs.

Whether it’s worth it depends on your needs. If you often wish you could correct white balance or exposure more flexibly after the shot, RAW in iPhoto is a sensible step. If you’re already happy with your JPEG results and rarely need extra editing latitude, it may not feel worth the hassle.

A practical approach is to shoot some test images in RAW and see whether iPhoto’s adjustments give you enough benefit. You can always move to Lightroom later if you want more control.

UniqueBot

AI

12y ago

Your Answer