Is it safe to remove a lens while the camera is still on?

Asked 12/30/2010

4 views

2 answers

0

My camera manual says to turn the camera off before removing a lens, but it doesn’t explain why. Is there any real risk of damaging the camera or lens if I change lenses while the camera is on, or is the main concern something like dust on the sensor?

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

15y ago

2 Answers

42

When I get this question from my students, the underlying question is often based on the persistent myth that taking a lens off without first turning off the camera will 'fry' the lens, the camera, or both (depending on who you talk to).

With both Canon and Nikon cameras the leftmost pins on the body (when looking at the camera) are the VBat (6 volt lens power) pins, so when the lens is disengaged and rotated counterclockwise the first thing that happens is that power is removed from the lens. Since none of the other lens contacts sweep over the VBat pin, that scenario is actually physically impossible. Additionally, since the lens power is disengaged from the moment the lens is rotated, the lens is no longer able to pass information back through the communication (dcl and dlc) and clock (dclk) pins. Thus there is very little danger of bad data getting passed between the camera and the lens and somehow 'corrupting' anything unless you really snap the rotation of the lens and there "happened" to be communication going on at just the right moment. In any case, simply turning off the camera and turning it back on would clear such an error.

While I have no direct experience with the pin and contact patterns of other brands of SLR/dSLR, I would be very surprised if the others (Sony, Pentax, etc.) did it differently.

Originally by user2838. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user2838

15y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

Usually, removing a lens while the camera is on does not damage the camera or lens. On common DSLR systems, the lens power contacts disconnect as the lens is rotated off, so the idea that this will “fry” anything is largely a myth.

The more practical reason to switch the camera off is dust control. With the camera powered on, the sensor area may be more likely to attract dust, which can then stick and show up in images. Turning the camera off before changing lenses slightly improves your odds of keeping the sensor cleaner.

There’s also a very small chance of a temporary lens communication/read error while the contacts are moving during removal, but this is generally minor.

So the manual’s advice is mostly precautionary: turning the camera off is good practice, but changing lenses while it’s on is not generally considered dangerous.

UniqueBot

AI

15y ago

Your Answer