Is it safe to include the sun in frame, and how do focal length and aperture affect the risk?
Asked 5/6/2018
56 views
2 answers
0
I’ve seen wide-angle photos that include the sun, but also warnings about camera or eye damage from aiming longer lenses at it. Is there any focal-length range that’s generally safe for having the sun in frame if I’m just quickly composing and taking the shot, with no filters? What other factors matter, such as the sun’s height, atmospheric conditions, or lens aperture? I’m especially concerned about common kit zooms like 18-55mm f/4-5.6 and 55-200mm f/4.5-5.6, and about briefly looking through the viewfinder while supervising a child using the camera.
Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
Photography Stack Exchange contributor
8y ago
2 Answers
5
The variables:
Height of the sun above the horizon. The closer the sun is to the horizon, the more atmosphere it has passed through before you see it. The atmosphere reflects, absorbs, and dissipates this energy so that less of it reaches a viewing location on the ground.
The optical density of the atmosphere. Clear dry air allows much more of the sun's energy to reach the surface than air thick with water vapor and other particulates in it. On heavily overcast days the position of the sun can not be seen at all from the surface. Most days at most places are somewhere in between these two extremes.
- Lens focal length/magnifying power/maximum aperture. The size of a lens' entrance pupil (effective aperture) determines how much of the sun's energy is collected by the lens. The larger the entrance pupil, the more energy is collected when all of the other variables are constant.
- The length of time the lens collects the sun's energy. The longer a lens is pointed at the sun the more energy it collects. Heat that is collected faster than it can be dissipated raises the internal temperature of the camera. If the components get too hot, they can be damaged.
The same is true of the human retina, which is generally less tolerant of direct exposure to the sun's energy than most modern cameras. Heat that is pumped into an eye faster than the body can dissipate it can "cook" the rods and cones in the retina, leading to permanently impaired visual function or even total blindness. Since the retina has no pain receptors, you won't even feel it as the infrared energy from the sun heats your retinal tissue. The effect of the damage from that heat can take up to several hours, so by the time you realize you have a problem it is far too late to do anything about it.
Due to the large number of variables and the wide range of variability for each of them there is no single focal length that one can say definitively is the line of demarcation between 'safe' and 'unsafe.' On a totally overcast day it might be possible to point an 800mm f/5.6 lens directly at the sun for an extended time with no ill effects. On a bright, cloudless day in a high desert, it might not be safe to point a very wide angle lens at the sun for much more than a second or two. Maybe even less.
I've never seen an official statement by a camera manufacturer that says it is safe to point a camera to the sun at all without proper filtration that absorbs not only about 15 stops of visible light, but has the same attenuation for the sun's infrared and UV output. On the other hand, they all pretty much universally warn against looking directly at the sun in the viewfinder at any time with any lens.
Originally by user15871. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user15871
8y ago
0
Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.
There isn’t a single “safe focal length.” Risk depends on how much solar energy the lens collects and concentrates, not just focal length alone.
Main factors:
- aperture/entrance pupil: a larger effective aperture gathers more light and heat
- focal length/magnification: longer lenses project a larger solar image and make direct viewing more hazardous
- sun position: the sun is less intense near the horizon because its light passes through more atmosphere
- atmospheric clarity: clear, dry air transmits more energy than haze, moisture, smoke, or cloud
A camera lens can act like a burning glass. Wide-angle lenses are generally less hazardous than telephotos, but they are not automatically “safe.” Longer lenses and larger apertures increase the chance of eye damage through an optical viewfinder and can potentially overheat or damage camera internals if aimed at the sun.
Practical advice: avoid looking at the sun through an optical viewfinder at any focal length. Be especially cautious with telephoto lenses. If the sun must be in frame, compose quickly, use live view/screen instead of the optical finder when possible, and don’t leave the camera pointed at the sun. Extra care is warranted when a child is handling the camera.
Recommended products
UniqueBot
AI8y ago
Your Answer
Related Questions
Is it dangerous to look at the sun through a DSLR viewfinder?
Can photographing the sun damage a camera sensor or other parts?
How do constant-aperture zoom lenses maintain the same f-number when zooming?
Can pointing a DSLR at the sun damage the camera, and is there a safe rule of thumb?
Why does a zoom lens’s maximum aperture get smaller as you zoom in?