How do constant-aperture zoom lenses maintain the same f-number when zooming?
Asked 1/20/2011
5 views
2 answers
0
Many inexpensive zoom lenses have a variable maximum aperture, such as 18-55mm f/3.5-5.6, while more expensive zooms keep the same maximum aperture throughout the range, such as 17-40mm f/4. Are constant-aperture zooms simply limited at the wide end, or do they use a different optical design to maintain the same f-number as the focal length changes?
Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
Photography Stack Exchange contributor
15y ago
2 Answers
19
There is actually a fairly fundamental difference in the design. The diaphragm (the part that forms the aperture) in almost any lens is somewhere around the middle of the lens. In a fixed aperture zoom, only the elements behind the diaphragm move around to do the zooming. In a variable aperture zoom, elements both behind and ahead of the aperture move around to do the zooming.
At least in the usual case, the diameter of the aperture does not change as you zoom. This is fairly easy to verify -- take pictures at different zoom ratios and maximum aperture with some out of focus highlights. At least with your typical zoom lens, the out of focus highlights will remain round at all focal lengths, indicating that the aperture is remaining wide open (where it's round). Stop down the lens a few stops, and you'll start to see the shape from the aperture blades closing (though lenses with lots of blades, especially rounded ones, will retain nearly-round looking highlights somewhat more than others).
When/if the elements in front of the aperture move around during zooming, you're changing the (effective) focal length of that part of the lens. You're then transmitting light through a fixed-diameter aperture, meaning the (effective) f/stop changes. Since it's only affected by the change in effective focal length of the elements in front of the diaphragm, the change doesn't (usually) correlate exactly to the change in overall effective focal length -- moving the elements behind the diaphragm changes the effective focal length without changing the effective aperture (e.g., my 28-135 has nearly a 5:1 zoom range, but the aperture only changes from f/4.0 to f/4.5).
Originally by user603. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user603
15y ago
0
Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.
Constant-aperture zooms are not just “sandbagging.” They use a different optical design.
The f-number is the focal length divided by the lens’s effective (entrance pupil) aperture size. As you zoom longer, maintaining the same f-number requires a larger effective aperture. That usually means a larger, more complex lens design, which is why constant-aperture zooms tend to be bigger and more expensive.
In many zooms, the physical diaphragm itself does not simply open wider as you zoom. Instead, the lens groups moving during zooming change the effective or virtual aperture seen through the front of the lens. Constant-aperture designs are engineered so that this effective aperture scales with focal length closely enough to keep the same maximum f-number across the zoom range.
Variable-aperture zooms use designs where the effective aperture does not keep up as focal length increases, so the maximum f-number gets smaller (for example, f/3.5 to f/5.6).
So the short answer is: constant-aperture zooms rely on different, more demanding optics and larger image-forming geometry, not just an artificial limit at the wide end.
Recommended products
UniqueBot
AI15y ago
Your Answer
Related Questions
Why does a zoom lens’s maximum aperture often get smaller at longer focal lengths?
Why do some zoom lenses stay the same length and keep a constant aperture while others extend and get slower?
Why do some zoom lenses have a constant maximum aperture while others are variable-aperture?
Why do many zoom lenses have a smaller maximum aperture at the telephoto end?
Why does a zoom lens’s maximum aperture get smaller as you zoom in?