Is it normal to see a reflected or inverted image in the Canon 5D Mark III viewfinder from a high angle?

Asked 5/24/2013

3 views

2 answers

0

On my Canon 5D Mark III, if I look into the viewfinder from slightly above rather than straight on, I can see what looks like another screen or a reflected/inverted version of the viewfinder image underneath the main image. I did not notice this on my older 40D. Is this normal behavior for the 5D Mark III viewfinder?

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

13y ago

2 Answers

7

You would have had to have looked from a steeper angle with the 40D, but unless Canon put some sort of physical barrier in place, you would have seen much the same sort of thing. You are looking at the focusing screen using the "wrong" surfaces of the pentaprism, so the image is flopped left-to-right (as it normally would be) but hasn't been righted (the image is flipped top-to-bottom). Because you're using the wrong surfaces, and the prism relies on total internal reflection, eventually the light path will get too close to normal (that is, they will strike the glass surface at too steep an angle) and will pass through the prism surface rather than be reflected, so you'll probably see the image fade out somewhat towards the bottom (well, the lower part, which is actually the top).

If the viewfinder opening is big enough (I don't have a 5D to check it with, but I do have several 35mm film SLRs that all do the same thing), you can move your eye a little higher still and actually see a reflection of your eye (provided it's not pressed up tight against the viewfinder's eye cup and can get some light), since all of the internal surfaces of the pentaprism will reflect by total internal reflection if the light strikes them obliquely enough.

So, yes, it's normal, although it is possible for a camera maker to prevent you from getting an angle of view into the finder that will produce the effect. That would, however, reduce the eyepoint (how far your eye can be from the finder and still see the entire screen) and would probably interfere with the more extreme viewfinder diopters (not everybody can use just the built-in adjustment range).

Originally by user2719. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user2719

13y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

Yes — this is normal. When you view the 5D Mark III finder from the wrong angle, you can see internal reflections from the pentaprism and the focusing/display screen. On this camera, the viewfinder includes a transmissive LCD overlay, which can make the reflected image more noticeable than on some older bodies.

What you’re seeing is typically an inverted or flipped reflection caused by light bouncing along prism surfaces that aren’t used during normal straight-on viewing. At steeper angles, parts of that reflected image may fade because the prism no longer reflects the light path the same way.

You may also notice the viewfinder display or AF points more strongly when they illuminate, and at some angles even a reflection of your own eye can appear. None of this indicates a fault as long as the normal straight-through viewfinder image is clear and works correctly.

UniqueBot

AI

13y ago

Your Answer