Is it a red flag when an online photo contest solicits your work first and only later asks for an entry fee?

Asked 6/20/2018

6 views

2 answers

0

I was contacted on Instagram by a website that said they feature artwork like mine and invited me to upload one of my photos. After I submitted it, I got another message saying I was invited to enter a magazine competition and had been preselected for the next round. Only at that stage did the site disclose an entry fee to submit images.

I know some legitimate photography contests charge entry fees, but in this case they approached me first, praised my work, and only later revealed the payment requirement. Is that normal practice for a legitimate contest, or is it a warning sign? Should photographers also be concerned about image rights when responding to offers like this?

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

8y ago

2 Answers

67

Legit contests which have entry fees have those fees because they get too many entries. Sure, they may offset some expenses, but basically the payment exists to make people think twice about entering. It's a basic "must be at least this serious to enter" bar.

The scam, on the other hand, is the opposite — they've reached out to you, and expend a lot of effort getting you hooked and then ask for money. Nothing legitimate ever works this way. Your instincts are right on the nose. Run away.

Like many scams, the basic hook here is an appeal to your ego — or vanity. It starts with someone complimenting your artwork, or your writing, or your business skill, or whatever. Human nature being what it is, we want to believe — which makes it easy to set aside skepticism and ignore warning flags.

On this particular scam, check out this forum thread for some people with personal experience, as well as some forensic investigation. Some choice quotes from that thread:

100% a scam. I reached out to artists who "won" (basically anybody who pays). People are told different things (pay to be promoted, art contest with distinguished panel of judges, magazine sold in Amsterdam, London and New York). Some bought copies of a magazine that never arrived. ISBN numbers of magazines "published" belong to other real publications.

and

I can now tell with 95% probability that 1340 art is a scam - don't pay money for attending into their odd competitions.

Currently at address of 1340 art in Netherlands is actually located Amsterdam Art, which has nothing to do with 1340 art.

Further, I note that the site touts a 5-star "Trustpilot" rating. Ironically, when you see this kind of thing front and center, that's a warning sign. Trustpilot is a real, independent thing, but they're famous for being full of false reviews. Indeed, the link on the site itself (which claims 5 stars and 8.8/10 as a rating) isn't clickable, but if you go and search, you find a three star 6.8/10 rating — and a long list of short, suspicious five-star reviews punctuated by one-star reviews from artists who were taken in. Take a look at the overview:

trustpilot

This is not a ... normal company profile.

Originally by user1943. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user1943

8y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

This is a strong warning sign, and the community consensus is: avoid it.

Legitimate contests sometimes charge entry fees, but those fees are usually disclosed upfront. The usual reason is to limit large numbers of submissions, not to lure people in through personal praise and then ask for money later.

The concerning pattern here is:

  • unsolicited contact
  • flattering messages about your work
  • being told you’re “selected” or “preselected”
  • only afterward being asked to pay

That approach is commonly associated with vanity-style scams. Even if a site is technically real, the value to you may be minimal while the business model depends on collecting fees from entrants.

Also read the terms carefully. Some contests claim broad usage rights to submitted images, and in the worst case you could give away more control than you intend.

So: no, this is not a reassuring pattern. If a contest isn’t transparent about fees and terms from the start, it’s safest not to participate.

UniqueBot

AI

8y ago

Your Answer