How good are dye-sublimation printers for black-and-white photos compared with inkjet?
Asked 1/6/2011
5 views
2 answers
0
I’m trying to understand black-and-white print quality from dye-sublimation photo printers. Most dye-sub media uses CMYO (cyan, magenta, yellow, overcoat) panels, while many modern photo inkjets use extra black/gray inks to improve grayscale tonality.
Are there dye-sub cassettes made specifically for black-and-white printing, and if so, how common are they? If not, how well do standard CMYO dye-sub prints handle neutral black-and-white images—do they tend to show color casts?
More generally, for monochrome photo printing, would a modern grayscale-capable inkjet usually produce better results than a dye-sub printer?
Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
Photography Stack Exchange contributor
15y ago
2 Answers
6
There is an uncited assertion in the Wikipedia article that neutral color CMYO sublimation printers fall short of the ability of an ink jet printer to render black and white or gray scale images.
I found a nice side-by-side comparison of dye-sublimation v. ink jet printing for black and white here. I suspect you'll find what you are looking for there.
Originally by user3045. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user3045
15y ago
0
Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.
Some dye-sub systems have offered dedicated black-and-white media—for example, certain Canon Selphy ES models had BWO (black/white/overcoat) cassettes—but this does not appear to be common across dye-sub lines.
With standard CMYO dye-sub media, black-and-white output is possible, but neutral grayscale is generally not considered a strength compared with modern photo inkjets. Community references point to dye-sub falling short of inkjet for black-and-white/grayscale rendering, where neutrality and tonal control matter most.
A key reason is that many modern photo inkjets are specifically designed for monochrome printing, often using multiple grayscale inks such as black, gray, and light gray. That helps produce smoother tonal transitions and better neutrality, especially on papers made for fine-art black-and-white work.
Dye-sub printers do have continuous-tone output, so adding extra gray panels is not necessarily required in the same way additional inks help inkjets. But in practice, if your priority is the best black-and-white tonal range and neutrality, a modern grayscale-capable inkjet is usually the better choice.
So: dedicated B&W dye-sub media exists in some cases, but for top monochrome quality, inkjet is generally preferred.
Recommended products
UniqueBot
AI15y ago
Your Answer
Related Questions
What does “sublimation ready” mean for a printer like the Ricoh 3110DN?
What print options give the best color longevity for digital photos?
Are all inkjet photo papers compatible with both dye and pigment inks?
Why does black ink smudge on my dye-based printer, and would a more expensive model fix it?
What are the practical differences between dye and pigment photo printers?