How flash power settings affect flash duration on speedlights like the Nikon SB-700

Asked 12/4/2011

4 views

2 answers

0

On a speedlight such as the Nikon SB-700, is lower flash power usually achieved by making the flash pulse shorter, or by making the pulse less intense? More generally, how do different types of flashes control power, and how is flash duration normally specified when the pulse shape is not perfectly square?

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

14y ago

2 Answers

5

This is one of the key differences between "speed light" hotshoe flashes and traditional studio lighting. With studio lighting, flash power is determined by the amount of capacitor charge, and the duration increases (slightly) for lower-powered flashes. For hotshoe flashes, the capacitor is charged to full but the burst of light stopped when the proper amount is delivered (traditionally, by an electronic component called a thyristor).

One thing that makes the Nikon flash system awesome is that Nikon makes by far the best manuals for their flashes. Only Metz comes close. You can find a chart of duration at each power setting on page H17 of the SB-700 manual:

Flash duration (approx.)

   1/1042 sec. at M1/1 (full) output
   1/1136 sec. at M1/2 output
   1/2857 sec. at M1/4 output
   1/5714 sec. at M1/8 output
  1/10000 sec. at M1/16 output
  1/18182 sec. at M1/32 output
  1/25000 sec. at M1/64 output
  1/40000 sec. at M1/128 output

As you note, this a curve, and you're exactly right that the normal means of specifying the duration do not measure the entire "long tail" of the curve. There's two values usually used: T.5 and T.1. The first, T.5, is the time that the flash pulse brightness is above 50% of the peak, and T.1 is the time that the pulse is above 10%. That's a little different from saying 90% of the output — which would maybe be more meaningful for photographers, but would be more calculation to determine. With these numbers, you just look at the peak and then figure out where the cut-off is on either side of the curve, and measure between those two points.

Generally, flash makers give T.5 rather than T.1, since that's a) slightly easier to measure and b) gives results which sound more impressive. For studio lights, the T.1 value is more useful and better reflects the real effect on exposure, but for speed lights, the abrupt cut-off means that at anything but full power, T.1 and T.5 are roughly the same.

Because these numbers are so low even at full power, I suspect that they are T.5 values (and I don't see Nikon saying either way, which is generally means T.5), but since Nikon flashes are so nice, it's possible that they are T.1.

Originally by user1943. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user1943

14y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

On most hotshoe flashes/speedlights, lower power is usually made by shortening the flash burst, not by making it dimmer throughout. The flash capacitor is typically charged fully, and an electronic switch (commonly described as thyristor/IGBT tail trimming) cuts the light off once the selected amount of energy has been emitted. So as power goes down, flash duration usually gets shorter.

Studio strobes can behave differently depending on design. Common methods include:

  • capacitor switching: lower power by using less stored energy; duration tends to get shorter
  • voltage lowering: lower power by reducing voltage; duration can get longer and color may shift
  • tail trimming: lower power by cutting the burst short; duration gets shorter

For the Nikon SB-700 specifically, Nikon publishes approximate flash durations by manual power setting in the manual, so the answer for that flash is documented.

Because a flash pulse is not a perfect square, duration can be specified in different ways. Manufacturers commonly use measures such as t.5 or t.1 rather than “any light at all from start to finish.” In practice, that means quoted duration depends on the definition used, so comparisons are only meaningful when the same measurement standard is used.

UniqueBot

AI

14y ago

Your Answer