How does Picasa handle RAW files compared with in-camera JPEGs?

Asked 7/21/2010

4 views

2 answers

0

When I shoot RAW+JPEG, the JPEG from my camera can look very different from the RAW file shown in Picasa. How does Picasa decide how to render a RAW image? Does it convert RAW files on import, and can I still do meaningful post-processing afterward, or is Picasa mainly for organizing and basic edits rather than true RAW development?

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

16y ago

2 Answers

13

I don't know all the technical details of how Picasa handles RAW files, but my short answer would be: "Dont even bother". There's a good blog post on using Picasa with RAW files.
Unfortunately the conclusion is that it's pretty much useless. Picasa is a photo management app with basic editing and sharing functionality not a RAW post-processor. Even Google makes it pretty clear. Here's a quote from Google Photos Blog:

Although Picasa’s RAW support will do a great job of helping you organize and share RAW-formatted files on your computer, Picasa doesn’t support super-sophisticated editing of RAW files. For this, you’ll need to use either the software that came with your camera, or purchase advanced photo-editing applications, like Aperture or Lightroom.

Don't get me wrong. There is nothing wrong with Picasa. It's very good at what it's made for. I use it all the time for basic JPEG editing and uploading baby snapshots to share with family, but when I need to process some RAW files I'll always go to Capture NX or Lightroom (one day when I figure out how to handle colors in Nikon's RAW files).

Originally by user125. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user125

16y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

Picasa’s RAW rendering won’t usually match your camera’s JPEG. Your camera applies its own built-in processing when it creates a JPEG—things like white balance, contrast, sharpening, and color style. A RAW file contains much more of the original sensor data, so software like Picasa has to interpret that data itself.

From the answers here, Picasa does some initial rendering of RAW files for viewing/import, but it is not considered a full-featured RAW processor. It’s mainly a photo management and basic editing tool. Like most editors, it does not directly change the RAW file; edits are typically stored separately and applied non-destructively.

So yes, you can do some post-processing in Picasa after import, but not “super-sophisticated” RAW editing. If you want close control over RAW development, the better choice is your camera maker’s software or a dedicated RAW editor such as Lightroom or Aperture. Picasa is more suitable for organizing, browsing, sharing, and simple adjustments than for serious RAW workflow.

UniqueBot

AI

16y ago

Your Answer