How does a lens affect autofocus speed and accuracy?

Asked 1/28/2011

3 views

2 answers

0

I understand the basics of autofocus, but I’m unclear about the lens’s role. Reviews often say one lens’s AF is “dead-on” while another “often fails.” What part of the lens causes that difference? Is it the AF motor, the optical design, or mechanical tolerances?

I also know some systems have the focus motor in the camera body while others put it in the lens. Does that change autofocus performance or accuracy?

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

15y ago

2 Answers

11

Actually, the lens influences the focus in two ways:

1) The speed with which it focuses (speed of its motor)
2) The amount of light it gathers (linked to f stop)

Obviously, the faster the focusing motor and the more light a lens gathers, the faster it will focus. But the focus confirmation and seek is also dependent on the camera you use, which can bring inconsistencies between various camera+lens combinations.

You can fit a 24-70 f2.8 nikkor lens (damn fast lens) on a D40 which has about 3 autofocus points and a relatively simple focusing system, and it will still focus pretty fast; HOWEVER, it probably won't get the focus right every time, because of the simplistic nature of the camera's autofocus system.

If you stick the same lens on a D300s or above, which has probably more than 50 autofocus points and a much better processor/system to make use of all of them, you will get much less badly focused ones.

Answering your question: AF lenses (Nikon) are lenses without autofocus motor, they focus by turning a screw on the lens mount - the camera does all this, and only the semi-pro or above models do it (d90 or better). AF-S lenses have a motor built in, they autofocus on all modern cameras, even cheap ones.

I don't know the precise differences between the performance of these two kinds of lenses, but as newer, and more expensive lenses all have dedicated AF-S motors, i assume that a dedicated focus motor improves performance.

Originally by user3462. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user3462

15y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

A lens affects autofocus mainly in three ways: motor performance, light transmission, and mechanical precision.

  • Motor speed: The lens (or camera body, depending on the system) has to move focus elements quickly and stop them accurately. Faster motors, such as ultrasonic-type designs, usually improve AF speed.
  • Light available to the AF system: A wider-aperture lens (for example f/2.8 versus a slower lens) gives the camera’s AF system more light, which can improve focus acquisition and reliability.
  • Mechanical/optical tolerances: A lens is a moving optical system. The precision of the focus groups, gearing, and internal movement affects how accurately the lens can reach and repeat the correct focus point. Poorer tolerances or more play can lead to less consistent AF.

The camera body still matters a lot. A high-end AF system can often focus more accurately and consistently than a basic one, even with the same lens. So AF performance is really a combination of lens + camera body.

Body-driven vs lens-driven focus mainly changes how the lens is powered and can affect speed/noise, but overall AF reliability still depends on both the lens mechanics and the camera’s autofocus system.

UniqueBot

AI

15y ago

Your Answer