How do you focus accurately with extension tubes, and can you focus stack with them?
Asked 4/19/2020
3 views
2 answers
0
I’m using extension tubes on a Nikon D5300 with a 35mm f/1.8 lens. With the tubes attached, it seems like the practical way to focus is by moving the camera or subject, especially when using multiple tubes. Is that normal? Are there better ways to control focus precisely, such as macro/focusing rails? Also, is focus stacking practical with extension tubes, given that focus changes seem to require changing camera-to-subject distance?
Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
Photography Stack Exchange contributor
6y ago
2 Answers
5
The only option to focus is to change the distance to the subject.
Basically, yes.
Is there any existing workaround?
A. Some rails are indeed one workaround rather than moving the tripod. There are some simpler models, like just a sliding plate on the head, like this one of the same brand.
B. Some other has some sliding bellows for both elements, the lens, and the camera.
C. But you can also use just a sheet of paper if you are on a table for example. Put the camera on a paper, a napkin or some smooth fabric and move it.
D. Another workaround is to move the subject, but of course, it depends on what your subject is.
E. If you are in a garden, one trick is to balance the tripod. Put two legs pointing to the front and the last leg pointing backward. If you extend or contract a bit this leg you will be also moving a bit forward and backward the camera. You need to compensate also the tilt of the head, but you have some more control than moving the tripod.
F. Another way to keep better focusing is by closing the aperture. Yes in some cases you need a great amount of light to compensate. So you probably need to fire a flash, or having some bright beam pointing at your subject. You could use some bright led lamp. Nowadays is easier and safer to have bright lights.
is focus stacking possible with extension tubes?
I suppose you always have some limitations because of the change of perspective, but focus stacking as far as I understand drop the zone that is not in focus. What you could have is some overall deformation.
Originally by user37321. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user37321
6y ago
0
Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.
Yes—this is normal. Extension tubes greatly reduce the lens’s usable focus range, especially with a short focal length like 35mm and longer tube combinations. The lens focus ring or autofocus may still work a little, but in practice you usually set magnification with the tube length and lens focus, then achieve critical focus by moving the camera or subject.
For better control, a macro focusing rail is a common solution. Even a simple sliding setup can help, but for precise repeatable movement—especially for focus stacking—a screw-driven focusing rail is much better than just shifting a tripod by hand.
Focus stacking is possible with extension tubes. The usual approach is to keep the magnification setup fixed and move the camera forward in small, regular steps. That does slightly change framing and perspective, but this is standard in macro work and stacking software is generally meant to handle small framing differences. Swapping tube lengths between shots is not a good stacking method because it changes magnification too much.
Recommended products
UniqueBot
AI6y ago
Your Answer
Related Questions
Macro focus stacking: when is a focusing rail better than turning the lens focus ring?
Can I stack two 25mm extension tubes on a Canon 100mm macro lens?
Why do extension tubes reduce maximum focus distance and enable closer focusing?
Should you edit photos before or after focus stacking?
How should I organize growing camera gear at home?
