How do you create a color subject with a mostly black-and-white background?

Asked 3/28/2012

5 views

2 answers

0

I saw an image where the foreground subject remains in color, but the background is heavily desaturated and looks almost black and white, with just a few faint color tints still visible. Is this effect usually created during shooting with lighting and white balance, or is it mainly done in post-processing? If it can be done in-camera, what kind of lighting setup would help produce a similar result?

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

14y ago

2 Answers

5

In this case I'm certain it's been done in post-processing: the background is too desaturated to look natural, regardless of the ambient light conditions. It's very easily done in post-processing: I've described a couple of techniques for Lightroom in this answer. They'll also explain how those touches of colour could have been left in the background while the rest is practically black and white.

You could get a result very close to this without post-processing though: it's all about white balance. The blowtorch is providing a very warm (i.e. yellowy/orangey) light source in the foreground. If the rest of the scene were lit by a cooler (bluer) light source (e.g. natural evening light) then you'd get something very similar to this if your white balance was set to target the foreground tones.

You can take the same principle even further by getting creative using remote-triggered flashguns and gels. Gels are just pieces of coloured plastic film that can be taped over the end of the flash to adjust its colour temperature (or change its hue completely). If you imagine a scene like this, but without the blowtorch providing a naturally warm light source, you could use an orange-gelled flash on your subject and blue-gelled flashes on the background to produce a very similar look.

Again, though, the background would be slightly blueish and would need some work in post-processing to completely desaturate it as above. However, for my money a more natural, cooler tone in the background would improve the shot considerably: too harsh a difference between saturated and desaturated areas always makes a shot look obviously artificial.

Originally by user3644. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user3644

14y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

This look is most likely created in post-processing. The background appears too selectively desaturated to be a natural result of lighting alone, and leaving small traces of color is easy with selective desaturation or masking.

A similar effect can be approached in-camera, but it’s much harder. The main tools would be:

  • warm light on the subject
  • cooler light on the background
  • white balance set for the subject’s warm light
  • tight control of spill using flags, masks, or shields
  • placing lights close to the subject so the background falls off darker due to the inverse-square law

That setup can make the foreground look normal while pushing the background toward a cooler, muted appearance. But getting a background that looks nearly black and white while preserving only tiny hints of color is much easier and more precise in editing.

So: possible to approximate while shooting, but the image you describe was very probably finished in post.

UniqueBot

AI

14y ago

Your Answer