How do two-piece wide-angle/macro screw-on converters work, and why won’t the wide section focus by itself?
Asked 8/15/2012
3 views
2 answers
0
I bought a screw-on “0.43x super wide angle” converter that separates into two parts: a wide-angle section and a macro section. Mounted together on my Sigma 18-50mm lens, it gives some wider coverage, but not nearly the advertised 0.43x effect. On its own, the wide section gives a much wider view, but I can’t get anything in focus, even with manual focus. Do these converters need both sections attached for normal wide-angle use, with the macro section only removable for close-up work? Or is this likely just poor optical quality / misleading marketing?
Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
Photography Stack Exchange contributor
14y ago
2 Answers
2
By reading the other reviews on Amazon, it sounds like you aren't the only one that has issues with this device focusing. Some people use it as a paperweight for example. One user did mention that they use a standard kit 18-55mm zoom lens and at 35mm only about 25% of the image is in focus. That sounds very similar to what you described as "can not get anything in focus".
Although I am not certain, based on the information given in the description:
This excellent lens can be separated in two pieces when unscrewed - the macro part and the wide angle part. As such, it can be used both ways - as a macro-only lens and as a wide angle with macro.
It sounds like the unit might require you to have both the macro and wide angle pieces attached at the same time for wide angle use. I agree this would be misleading to sell the unit as a .43x wide angle lens, but keep in mind they also state that:
GUARANTEED TO NOT DISTORT THE PICTURE!
Originally by user4892. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user4892
14y ago
0
Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.
Based on the reports in the community answers, this is most likely how the attachment is intended to work: the wide-angle converter is designed to be used with the matching rear section attached, and removing that section turns it into a close-focus/macro element rather than a normal-focus wide converter.
So if the wide section alone won’t focus at normal distances, that’s expected. The “macro” part is not just optional support glass for wide-angle use; it helps make the combined unit focus properly on your lens.
As for the weak real-world widening and poor image quality, that also matches what others reported for similar low-cost screw-on converters. These attachments often don’t deliver their claimed magnification cleanly across the frame, especially on zoom lenses, and may only work acceptably over a limited focal-length range.
So yes: you likely need both pieces together for wide-angle use, and yes: the advertised performance may be optimistic. If you want reliable wide-angle results, a dedicated wider lens will usually perform much better than a front-mounted converter.
Recommended products
UniqueBot
AI14y ago
Your Answer
Related Questions
Are screw-in wide-angle adapters worth it for better APS-C wide-angle shots?
Can I use a wide-angle converter on a Nikon 35mm f/1.8 lens?
Are screw-on wide-angle and macro converter attachments safe to use on a kit lens, and how is the image quality?
Can I use front-mounted telephoto/wide converters on a Canon 1100D DSLR?
Can a 52mm 0.4× wide-angle converter fit a Nikon 18-55mm kit lens with a 55mm thread?