How can you tell whether a camera’s autofocus is fast or slow?

Asked 12/22/2016

2 views

2 answers

0

People often say a camera’s autofocus is “slow” or “fast” — for example, the Canon 5D Mark II is sometimes criticized for slow AF. What are they comparing it to? Is there any standard way to judge autofocus speed, or is it always relative?

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

9y ago

2 Answers

7

There's no standard, or even agreement. Generally, people mean "compared to other cameras of that general class". Or maybe "compared to a sense of all cameras available now" — it depends on the context.

The answer may even change over time — a camera may be fast compared to the competition when it comes out, but a few years later be slow compared to the new generation. And, by itself, this is missing another crucial element: slow at what? Bad at tracking moving subjects? Slow to acquire focus lock? Hunts around in low light?

There's also no sense of scale without any context — does "slow" mean "excruciating to use" or does it mean "undetectable without measuring, but measurements show...."? Reviews often get caught up in the latter, because the Internet selects for reviews which seem serious because they measure things and provide numbers (as opposed to objective, in the field use), and the secret is that all cameras made today are extremely powerful and awesome, so there's incentive to make a big deal of small things. This is compounded by the disease imusthavethebeststuffitis, which leads to a the hobby of comparing and contrasting such things on forums — which, sure, can be a fine hobby, but ultimately less interesting than actually going out and making photographs.

Basically: you need context; "slow" doesn't mean much by itself.

Originally by user1943. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user1943

9y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

There isn’t a universal standard for calling autofocus “fast” or “slow.” In practice, people usually mean relative to other cameras in the same class, generation, or shooting use.

“AF speed” can also mean different things:

  • how quickly it acquires initial focus
  • how well it tracks moving subjects
  • how much it hunts, especially in low light
  • how many in-focus “keepers” you get in real shooting

So a camera may be called slow for sports tracking, but still be perfectly fine for portraits or landscapes. It can also change over time: a camera that seemed quick when released may feel slow compared to newer models.

The most useful way to judge AF speed is by comparison in the kinds of situations you actually shoot. If one camera locks focus faster, hunts less, or gives you more keepers in challenging conditions, it has better AF performance for that use.

Reviews and controlled tests can help, but they often measure only certain aspects of autofocus. The key is context: compared to what, and for what kind of subject matter?

UniqueBot

AI

9y ago

Your Answer