How can you make people stand out against a flat-looking background in portraits?
Asked 3/4/2019
2 views
2 answers
0
I saw these portraits shot outdoors around midday on a slightly overcast day. The subjects stand out strongly from backgrounds that look muted and less prominent. It doesn’t seem likely that each image was built from a complex multi-frame composite, since the photographer was shooting many portraits in a session.
What techniques—either in-camera or in post-processing—would most likely create this look? For example, is it mainly subject/background masking with different color treatment, or could it be done mostly with lighting and depth of field?
Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
Photography Stack Exchange contributor
7y ago
2 Answers
24
I'd guess it's as simple as selecting the subject in Photoshop - with a tad more care & attention than I've used below, then leeching out the saturation in the background & tonally balancing towards a sepia effect.
As a very quick demo I did the same thing but made it a pretty garish purple instead.
Once you have your mask you can treat inside & outside of it in totally different ways.
The subjects have been left with realistic colouration, which I think is what is providing the majority of the visual separation - that & the physical separation from the ground, which pushes them into the unsharp area of the background. Note how the effect is less emphatic on the small boy, especially lower, where he's connected to the equally sharp ground at that distance.
I don't think the focus has been played with. I think it was shot on a wide enough aperture that the background is blurred by simple distance. The ground underneath them is still reasonably sharp.
I also don't think it would be compulsory to be using flash, so long as enough light was getting in, or set to a high-enough ISO, to use a short exposure.
The light on the people & the trees seems to match - little to no shadow at all, which matches the OP's description & the almost 'white-out' cloud cover in the back of the shot.
Late addition
I'm not seeing any hint of even a slight fill-flash. Shadows just don't match, & there's not the faintest hint of a catch-light in the eyes.
Additionally, for the 'ooh it's a composite' voices.
The two backgrounds will not overlay, no matter how much you stretch them or play with the perspective - so the 'trick' of extracting the subjects & pasting into a separate shot of the orchard would have required 2 different shots of the background, taken from 2 slightly different places. The photographer would then have had to cut the subjects out of a background they were already in, to replace it with another, taken on the same day at around the same time in approximately the same place... to what end?
That just makes no sense.
Originally by user57929. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user57929
7y ago
0
Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.
The look is likely a combination of simple subject separation techniques rather than an elaborate composite.
Most likely methods:
- Selective post-processing: mask/select the people, then treat subject and background differently. A common approach is to keep natural color on the subjects while reducing saturation and shifting the background toward a muted/sepia tone.
- Shallow depth of field: using a wider aperture blurs the background so the eye goes to the sharp subjects.
- Lighting contrast: fill flash or brighter light on the subjects with a slightly darker background can make them pop.
From the examples, the strongest effect seems to come from natural-looking subjects against a desaturated, tonally shifted background, plus some background blur. Flash may also have been used to keep the people brighter than the scene behind them.
So yes: this can often be done with a subject mask and separate adjustments to foreground and background, but the result is stronger when the image is also shot with good subject/background distance, wider aperture, and possibly fill flash.
Recommended products
UniqueBot
AI7y ago
Your Answer
Related Questions
How can I make white backgrounds match across a batch of photos?
Can blown-out subject edges against a white backdrop be recovered in post?
How can I recreate this moody, low-contrast portrait look in Lightroom?
Can you convincingly replace a background when the subject is leaning against a green screen at an angle?
How can I recreate this portrait look: strong facial detail, muted cyan tones, and low-contrast light?
