How can I tone map a very large HDR panorama after stitching?

Asked 4/23/2016

7 views

2 answers

0

I have a stitched 360° panorama built from about 1,400 bracketed shots (-1.3/0/+1.3), resulting in roughly a 5 gigapixel image. I can assemble the panorama in Autopano Giga, but I’m struggling to tone map the final HDR because of file size and software limits.

What I’ve tried:

  • Exporting a layered PSB from Autopano; Photoshop won’t tone map it.
  • Exporting an HDR and opening it in Photomatix; saving as TIFF runs into large-file issues.
  • Exporting individual TIFFs and merging in Photomatix; it crashes after the HDR merge.

I’d prefer to avoid tone mapping before stitching, because that can create visible exposure differences across a 360° pano. What workflow or software can handle tone mapping an HDR panorama this large?

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

10y ago

2 Answers

3

It turns out I manged to find a way to tonemap this monster of an image. Theoretically this should work for any image size up to 300000x300000 (90GP), which is the maximum supported by Photoshop. Of course, a full 360x180 panorama would end up as 300000x150000 (45GP). Either way, most likely not on anyone's radar, even mine. I suspect at those resolutions a dedicated panoramatic head is required, and its associated stitching software.

Onto the procedure!

  1. Export from Autopano Giga in Radiance HDR format. I tried a few different options but in the end Radiance HDR provided the best compatibility in the next step. Time: ~12 hours
  2. Using VIPS, transform this .hdr into a BigTIFF file. This is done using the vips tiffsave command, which takes HDR but not OpenEXR (the two 32-bit formats supported by Autopano). Time: ~15 minutes
  3. Open the .tiff in Photoshop. Save as a .psb immediately. Time: ~1 hour

Overall, not a particularly involved process when you get it down. Unfortunately, it turns out that there was only one combination of likely hundreds of image processing programs and libraries, and file formats, which is capable of this. I expect to make more panoramas in this format, and most likely in the same size (using the same 135mm/3.5 prime lens), and so far this seems reliable enough on my system. I'll edit this answer later to show the completed panorama.

Originally by user50815. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user50815

10y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

A workable approach is to keep the panorama in HDR through stitching, then convert it into a large-file format that your editor can handle.

From the community answers, one successful workflow was:

  1. Stitch/export from Autopano Giga as Radiance HDR.
  2. Convert that HDR into a BigTIFF using VIPS.
  3. Open and tone map the BigTIFF in Photoshop.

That avoids the normal 4 GB TIFF limitation and lets Photoshop handle extremely large images, within its own pixel-dimension limits.

Another suggested workflow is to first merge each bracket set to 32-bit HDR files in Photomatix, skip tone mapping there, and then stitch the HDR data. This can be more memory-efficient than handling multiple LDR bracket files separately. If your files have correct EXIF exposure data, pre-merging should not introduce uneven exposure.

PTGui was also recommended as a strong HDR panorama tool, including workflows designed for stitching bracketed panoramas before final tone mapping.

So the practical answer is: use an HDR-first workflow, and if standard TIFF export breaks, convert the stitched HDR to BigTIFF with VIPS before tone mapping in Photoshop.

UniqueBot

AI

10y ago

Your Answer