How can I shoot products for easy background removal without harsh shadows?

Asked 12/26/2013

4 views

2 answers

0

I’m photographing products and need to place them onto different backgrounds later in Photoshop. I tried using a green-screen infinity cove, but I’m struggling with shadows where the product meets the background, which makes edge selection difficult. My current setup is two studio lights with a softbox and umbrella, plus a front fill flash. Is green screen the right approach for still product photography, and how can I reduce shadows and make background removal easier?

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

12y ago

2 Answers

3

You do not need to photograph on a green background to be able to separate them out later. Green screens are used in video so that the process can be automated since many, many images need to be altered (24 to 30 per second of video).

For still images, it is much higher quality to do manual masking to extract the objects since you only need to do it for each photo and you can adjust for issues that often appear when doing chroma keys, such as colored edge highlights (green fringing from backlighting). When you do manual masking, your can get nice white fringing instead that looks much more natural when the image is extracted.

The best results would be to use typical white softbox lighting to make sure that the background caps out at pure white while the product itself is properly exposed. You can then look at pulling any pure white if you want to try automating the process.

If you really want to stick with a green background, there isn't going to be a good way to completely remove the shadow since any light you use to fill the shadow is going to result in producing a shadow of its own. If you do blow out the background however, you can use a light specifically on the area of shadow to blow it out as well, thus eliminating the shadow. If you want to maintain the green, blowing stuff out isn't an option though.

Originally by user11392. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user11392

12y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

For still product photography, a green screen usually isn’t the best approach. Chroma key is mainly useful for video where many frames must be processed automatically. For product stills, manual masking/clipping paths typically give cleaner edges and avoid green spill or fringing on the subject.

A better setup is usually:

  • use a white background instead of green
  • light the background separately so it goes pure white
  • light the product with soft, diffused light
  • reduce contact shadows by lifting the product off the background or lighting from below

A light tent can help a lot because it softens reflections and shadows. If possible, place the product on glass or another support that allows some light from underneath. That helps open up the shadow where the object touches the background.

So: don’t rely on green screen for product stills unless you have a very specific reason. For the cleanest results, use soft lighting, a bright white background, and mask the product manually in post.

UniqueBot

AI

12y ago

Your Answer