How can I separate dark trees better in a black-and-white landscape?
Asked 9/9/2014
3 views
2 answers
0
I converted a landscape photo to black and white and I like the way the sky and rocks look, but the trees in the lower-right are blending together too much. Is there a good way to improve their separation and contrast in post-processing, or is that detail basically lost because of how the image was shot? I still have the original color file.
Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
Photography Stack Exchange contributor
11y ago
2 Answers
6
If your editor allows tweaking individual amount of colors that come to the mix, try changing amount of green and yellow. This will allow you to brighten or darken parts of the trees and bring more separation there. Different editors allow different amount of manipulation. In the worst case, you could make the color image more yellow or green before converting to b&w and use trial & error method to get the best look.
Another techniques would be:
- Selecting the trees (or greens) and adding Clarity or USM with large radius to those areas
- Drawing local corrections of brightness or contrast to the green areas by mouse
... and probably many others that would work...
Originally by user27944. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user27944
11y ago
0
Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.
Yes—there’s often room to improve it in post, especially if you have the original RAW file. In black-and-white conversion, try adjusting the color channel mix, especially the green and yellow sliders, to lighten or darken different parts of the trees and create more separation. If your editor is limited, you can first shift the color image slightly toward green or yellow, then convert again and compare results.
Local adjustments can also help: selectively mask the trees and add clarity, local contrast, or a large-radius sharpening/USM effect. You can also use curves to lift deep shadows slightly and steepen tonal separation in the dark areas so near-black tones don’t all merge together.
More advanced options include blending multiple versions of the same image with different brightness/contrast settings using masks, or applying adaptive/local contrast enhancement only where needed.
Be aware that opening up dark areas can reveal noise, so some cleanup may be needed. Work from the RAW file and at high bit depth if possible to preserve smooth tones and avoid banding.
Recommended products
UniqueBot
AI11y ago
Your Answer
Related Questions
How can I make a black-and-white conversion look less dull and more punchy?
Does black-and-white film have advantages over converting a digital color photo to monochrome?
How can I get very crisp tree detail like this landscape photo?
How can I reduce noise and avoid an unnaturally bright sky in night cityscape photos?
How can I make a flat overcast sky look better in photos?