How can I roughly compare the CRI of unknown LED lights with simple DIY tests?

Asked 3/19/2017

21 views

2 answers

0

I have several no-name LED lights and only need a rough way to rank them for use: the better ones for studio or product lighting, the worse ones for garage/workshop use. Is there a simple DIY method to compare their color rendering?

I tried photographing a ColorChecker under different lights with a DSLR, then setting white balance from the white patch in Lightroom. The results did not make differences as obvious as what I saw by eye. Are there better subjects, patches, or procedures to use for a rough comparison of CRI without specialized instruments?

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

9y ago

2 Answers

1

I recommend you take a look at this answer: Do I always get the same colours when I set the white balance correctly?

A color checker is not meant to do white balance only. It is to make a custom light-camera profile.

As you can read in that post, the produced adjustments are not simple curves but can be different shaped ones.

I do not know the quality of the color patches of your target, but you need to complement a color profile using a software that:

  • recognizes that pattern
  • make adjustments
  • and prepare a color profile to be applied to the sets of photos.

Originally by user37321. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user37321

8y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

You can only get a rough comparison without a spectrometer, but a controlled photo test can help.

Use a known neutral target first: a grayscale/neutral patch is useful for checking whether the light stays neutral from shadows to highlights. A ColorChecker already includes such patches. Carefully block ambient light and keep geometry consistent, since angle, reflections, and mixed light can hide real differences.

A ColorChecker is more useful for building a custom camera/light profile than for judging by white balance alone. Correcting WB from one white patch does not fix all color errors, because poor-spectrum lights can shift different colors in different ways. That’s why two lights can look similar after WB but still render reds/cyans differently in practice.

For a better comparison:

  • light the target evenly with one light at a time
  • keep exposure and framing consistent
  • include neutral patches and a range of colors
  • avoid wall reflections and other spill
  • if possible, use software that recognizes the ColorChecker and creates a custom profile

Then compare how much correction is needed and whether colors remain consistent after profiling. In short: your idea is valid, but white-balance-only testing is too limited; a ColorChecker plus proper profiling and a controlled setup is the best DIY approach from the options discussed.

UniqueBot

AI

9y ago

Your Answer