Does adding a color gel to a flash reduce its CRI?
Asked 8/24/2022
4 views
2 answers
0
I know many decorative lights, like some Christmas lights, can have poor color rendering and make skin tones look bad. A flash has much better color rendering, but ungelled flash can spoil the warm atmosphere of the scene. If I put a gel on the flash to match the ambient light color, will that still give me better color rendering than the original low-CRI light, or does the gel significantly reduce the flash’s CRI?
Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
Photography Stack Exchange contributor
3y ago
2 Answers
3
Any color bias to a light source results in a lower CRI.
CRI is based on color reproduction compared to full spectrum daylight (midday sun), which a flash is designed to closely approximate. If you absorb a portion of that spectrum with a filter, then it cannot accurately reproduce the colors that depend upon those wavelengths that are now missing.
However, CRI is an average... it is probably possible to have very high accuracy in the majority of colors and one very weak spot, and have a better/equal CRI compared to a light source that doesn't reproduce any colors particularly well.
Originally by user70370. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user70370
3y ago
0
Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.
A gel can reduce a flash’s color rendering somewhat, but usually not by much. A bare flash is designed to approximate daylight fairly well, so it starts with good color rendering. Adding a gel changes the spectrum by attenuating some wavelengths more than others, which can lower CRI because some colors will be rendered less accurately.
That said, typical flash gels do not create severe “holes” in the spectrum. They usually just favor some wavelengths slightly over others. Light sources with genuinely poor CRI—such as sources missing large parts of the visible spectrum—tend to be much worse for skin tones and color accuracy than a gelled flash.
So in practice, a gelled flash will often still render color better than many low-CRI decorative lights, while also matching the scene’s warm look more closely. It won’t be perfect, and exact color accuracy may still be limited, but a gel generally does not devastate flash color rendering the way a poor-quality light source can.
Recommended products
UniqueBot
AI3y ago
Your Answer
Related Questions
Can CTO or CTB gels improve the CRI of an LED light?
Do color gels reduce flash output, and do I need to compensate?
Will a CTO gel make on-camera flash less noticeable in a dim cafe or bar?
Can a color target compensate for low-CRI lighting?
How can I lower ISO in a dark portrait without losing the contrast of Christmas lights?