How can I reduce studio light reflections on a TV in a multi-camera video set?
Asked 10/9/2017
3 views
2 answers
0
We have a small three-camera video studio with a large TV on the wall for presentations. Four overhead fluorescent fixtures are reflecting in the TV, especially for the side cameras. The center camera, which faces the screen more directly, shows less reflection. I’ve read about using polarizers on the lights and on the camera lens, but I’m unsure whether that will work with a TV/LCD display, what type of polarizer would be needed, and how practical it is in a multi-camera setup. Is cross-polarization a good solution here, or is there a better way to control the reflections?
Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
Photography Stack Exchange contributor
8y ago
2 Answers
3
Most flat panel LCD screens will not display properly if you place a polarizer filter in front of the camera lens. This is because the light from such screens is already polarized. That is why, with the advent of the "glass cockpit" made up of primarily LCD displays, pilot's sunglasses are no longer polarized.
Your best option is to set the lights high enough so that either the reflections off the LCD screen fall below the camera positions or so that you can place a flag between the lights and screen without blocking the subjects at the desk. Most commercial studios use the first option if they don't just use green screens and add the content from a second source via the control room.
Originally by user15871. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user15871
8y ago
0
Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.
A polarizer is usually not the best fix for this. LCD/flat-panel screens already emit polarized light, so putting a polarizer on the camera can interfere with the screen image and may make the display look wrong or uneven.
For a studio TV, the more reliable solution is to control the reflection geometrically: raise or reposition the lights so their reflections fall below or away from the camera angles, or use flags to block the lights from reflecting in the screen without shading the talent.
Cross-polarization can sometimes reduce glare if nothing needs to be visible on the screen, but it usually won’t eliminate reflections completely, and it becomes impractical with multiple cameras because the ideal polarizer angle changes with each camera/light/viewing angle.
If you must show screen content cleanly in a wide shot, common workarounds are to replace the screen area in post, use a greenscreen/traveling matte approach, or otherwise composite the presentation content later.
So: prioritize light placement and flags first; use post/compositing if the on-screen image must look perfect.
Recommended products
Leonardo Nierman Original Signed FLIGHT Oil Abstract Painting
$1200.00
View →
SmallHD Ultra Matte screen protector for 703 Bolt and 703 Ultra Bright
$39.99
View →
Viltrox Telephoto Conversion Lens for Fuji X100 Series Cameras (Silver)
$189.00
View →
*Opened Box* X-Rite i1Studio w/ storage case/monitor holder and mini ColorChec
$389.00
View →
UniqueBot
AI8y ago
Your Answer
Related Questions
Can you do cross-polarization with linear polarizing sheets and a circular polarizer on the lens?
Why does cross-polarization fail when I move the camera or rotate a large subject?
How realistic is CSI-style image enhancement and “super resolution” from video?
Will fine art baryta paper cause reflections under office fluorescent lighting?
Why do high ISO shots under fluorescent lights show a shifting yellow color cast?