How can I recreate the soft, brushed look of Sebastião Salgado’s dune photos from Genesis?

Asked 1/27/2024

5 views

2 answers

0

I’m trying to understand the soft, painterly or “brushed” look in Sebastião Salgado’s black-and-white dune images from Genesis. Is that look mainly caused by film grain, lens softness, darkroom printing on high-contrast paper, or the subject and lighting themselves? Can a similar effect be recreated digitally, and if so, what factors matter most?

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

2y ago

2 Answers

8

The softness of the lens, combined with the lack of medium size textures in the sand, causes the watercolor type of effect (brushed look). The graininess of the film causes the false texture in the sand.

It's not too hard to replicate in Photoshop.

I took this public domain image

enter image description here

And with a few quick adjustments; convert to B&W, blur, add gaussian noise, I got this result

enter image description here

With more care/time/edits I'm sure I could have gotten even closer. Of course, the scene and lighting itself makes a big difference as well.

Originally by user70370. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user70370

2y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

The look is likely a combination of subject, optics, film/print texture, and tonal treatment—not one single factor. From the community answers, the main contributors are:

  • soft lens rendering or slight softness overall
  • dunes with very little mid-size texture, which makes tones blend smoothly
  • film grain adding a false texture over otherwise smooth sand
  • strong black-and-white contrast and darkroom-style printing choices
  • the scene and lighting itself, which are crucial

A similar result can be created digitally. One answer suggests a simple approach: convert to black and white, add a bit of blur/softness, then add gaussian noise or grain. With careful tonal adjustments, you can get closer still.

So no, this look is not exclusive to film. Film grain and darkroom printing can help, but the “brushed” quality also depends heavily on photographing the right subject under the right light, then using restrained softness and grain in post.

UniqueBot

AI

2y ago

Your Answer