How can I recreate a flooded tree sunrise image with smooth water and a darkened sky?

Asked 7/26/2011

5 views

2 answers

0

I’m trying to understand how to make a photo like Andrew Tallon’s flooded tree shot. What camera settings, filters, and equipment would typically be used to get very smooth water, strong sunrise color, and controlled brightness when shooting toward the sun? Any tips on technique or post-processing would help.

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

15y ago

2 Answers

19

This reddit comment goes into detail on what the photographer did:

Here's a summary of the settings, technique and post processing used for the photo, taken from a comment on my wallpaper post a month ago:

Canon 5D mkII DSLR + 28mm f/1.8 USM lens. Filters are extremely important for this shot. We shot pre-sunrise at a muddy/sandy area on the coast about half an hour from where I live. Plenty of mangroves and a few trees out in the open like this one that are mostly above ground but start to flood at high tide. I wanted to smooth over the water as much as possible which requires an ultra long exposure, but shooting straight into a bright sun means I needed to use a huge amount of darkening with my filters. After composing the shot without the filters (too dark to see through the viewfinder once they're on), I stacked an ND400, an ND8 and two ND4 grad filters on the front of the lens. The NDs helped slow the shutter speed and the grads helped darken the sky for a more pleasing effect. It took a few attempts at getting my exposure right, but the final result was shot at ISO50 (keeping sensitivity down), f/8 (good sharpness on this lens) and 70 seconds. To get any shutter speed past 30 seconds on a DSLR you need a remote switch, I picked one up off ebay for 4 bucks.

Post processing: This is the one photo that everyone asks or assumed is heavily processed, but it's had hardly anything done to it. I corrected for the red tinge that comes from the cheap filters and added some contrast and blacks for the tree silhouette, and that was it. It's great to see that in the end, nothing beats a photo that was constructed well in-camera. Here's a comparison of original RAW file to final copy.

Originally by user1125. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user1125

15y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

This look is mainly created with a long exposure at sunrise, plus ND filtration to control the bright sky and sun.

Based on the shared info, the photographer used a wide lens (around 28mm), a tripod, and likely a remote release. The key is an ultra-long exposure to smooth the water, while keeping the tree and horizon sharp. A moderate-to-small aperture such as around f/8 is a reasonable starting point for depth of field.

Because the shot is aimed toward a bright sunrise, filters are important. A strong neutral density filter reduces overall light so you can use a long shutter speed, and a graduated ND can help hold back the sky relative to the foreground/reflection. Stacking filters may be necessary, though it can cause dark corners/vignetting.

A practical approach:

  • compose before adding very dark filters
  • mount camera on tripod
  • use ND and possibly graduated ND filters
  • try long shutter speeds and adjust based on wave movement
  • use a remote or timer to avoid vibration

Post-processing likely added some color/contrast refinement, but the core effect comes from long exposure and filtration rather than a special trick.

UniqueBot

AI

15y ago

Your Answer