How can I photograph an object from directly above with minimal perspective distortion for tracing?

Asked 3/9/2017

6 views

2 answers

0

I’m photographing objects from a top-down setup to extract clean silhouettes/outlines for vector tracing and CNC cutouts. The object sits on an evenly lit surface, and I only really need a high-contrast silhouette. Using a Canon 750D with the 18–55mm kit lens, I’m seeing parts of the object look slightly slanted or thicker than they really are, especially where the object has some height. I first thought this was barrel distortion, but it may actually be perspective from the camera position.

What’s the best way to capture a near-orthographic top view with minimal distortion? Is there a lens or technique that helps, without getting into very expensive specialty gear?

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

9y ago

2 Answers

6

In order to get an orthographic view of your subject using a camera, you would need a telecentric lens. One requirement for a telecentric lens is that the width of the lens be at least as large as the widest object you wish to photograph using it. If your Sword is three feet long, then you would need a telecentric lens at least three feet in diameter...

One solution many people desiring an orthographic view of an object adopt is to use a scanner, rather than a camera. The optical collectors in a scanner move linearly as they collect each line of information. This insures that a constant angle is maintained from one end of the scanned object to the other. One can also use a camera to take multiple images of an object while moving the camera linearly along the length of the object being imaged, then combining them in a linear or parallel motion panorama.

Originally by user15871. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user15871

9y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

What you’re seeing is mostly perspective, not barrel distortion. If the camera isn’t effectively very far away and perfectly centered, parts of a 3D object with some height will appear shifted or thicker.

For a true orthographic view, you’d need a telecentric lens, but those are specialty optics and impractical/expensive for large objects.

Practical options:

  • Place the camera exactly centered above the subject.
  • Increase camera-to-subject distance and use a longer focal length to reduce perspective effects.
  • Keep the object as flat as possible.
  • If you only need the outline, a flatbed scanner is often the best solution because it captures line-by-line with a constant viewing angle.

Another possible workaround is to capture the object’s shadow instead of the object itself, since a shadow on a flat surface is inherently 2D. This only works well if the light rays are close to parallel and the projection surface is perpendicular to the light.

So: no normal inexpensive lens will give perfect zero-perspective top views; scanner or specialty telecentric optics are the real solutions, while longer focal lengths and more distance help minimize the problem.

UniqueBot

AI

9y ago

Your Answer