How can I handle scenes with very high contrast, such as harsh midday light?

Asked 1/25/2011

4 views

2 answers

0

In bright conditions like midday sun, the difference between highlights and shadows can exceed what the camera can record in a single exposure. Besides letting the highlights blow out or turning the subject into a silhouette, what techniques can help produce a usable image? For example, how can I keep detail in both the sky and a shaded subject?

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

15y ago

2 Answers

36

As others have stated the main options are fill flash or multi exposure. I thought I'd post this handy example I shot recently where I tried both techniques:

This is the result of using fill flash:

The flash was off camera and to the left, near the ground. I was intentionally trying to get a very dramatic lighting effect, had I used the flash on camera the shadows would be less dramatic and the light more even.

This is the result of two exposures manually merged into one file:

The fill flash shot is more effortlessly natural looking but the multi-exposure (or HDR if you prefer) definitely has more detail and is more striking. It's worth pointing out that whilst I could have done better with the flash I could also have done better with the exposure blending, this is just a quick job to prove a point.

In general the pros and cons of each method are

Fill flash

  • + Natural looking
  • + Can be done with film
  • + Can have movement in the scene
  • + Minimal post processing
  • - Only works for close subjects
  • - You may have to balance the colour of flash with ambient light
  • - Can be hard to get even lighting on your subject and avoid shadows
  • - Bright backgrounds mean you have to stop down lots or use an ND at you can't use a fast shutter (unless your flash has HSS)

Multi-exposure (HDR)

  • + More even lighting, no problems with shadows
  • + Striking images
  • + Can use any shutter speed
  • + Works with all subject, near and far
  • - Requires careful post processing to avoid halos, sickening contrast
  • - Other photographers will know you used HDR and secretly judge you ;)
  • - You can get weird colours in shadows due to secondary reflections.

This last point is worth expanding on. In my example the subject isn't being lit by direct sunlight. So where is the light coming from? Some of it is from other parts of the blue sky (refracting of particles in the upper atmosphere and turning blue), a small amount is bouncing off the clouds (which had almost gone by this point) but a significant amount of it is bouncing off the green grass in front of the subject.

If you boost the shadows too much using HDR, you can get colour shifts, as the shadows by definition aren't lit by direct light, only by light that has already bounced off other surfaces and picked up their colours!

Originally by user1375. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user1375

15y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

Common ways to handle high-contrast scenes are:

  • use fill light: A fill flash can brighten the shadowed subject while keeping the sky properly exposed. Off-camera flash can look dramatic; on-camera fill is usually more even. A reflector can do the same using natural light.
  • shoot RAW and expose carefully: RAW gives more room to recover shadows and highlights in post. Expose as far to the right as you safely can without clipping important highlights.
  • blend multiple exposures / HDR: Take one exposure for the bright areas and one for the shadows, then merge them later. This can retain the most detail.
  • reduce background brightness: A polarizer can darken and improve the sky in some situations.
  • change the scene if possible: Move the subject into better light or choose a different angle so the brightness difference is smaller.

In short, the main practical fixes are fill flash or reflector, careful RAW exposure, and exposure blending when the contrast is simply too great for one shot.

UniqueBot

AI

15y ago

Your Answer