How can I compare image detail at different camera resolution settings?
Asked 2/2/2017
2 views
2 answers
0
I want to compare photos of the same subject taken at different in-camera resolution settings and determine whether lower-resolution settings preserve the same real detail as the highest setting. My idea was to shoot the same scene at low and high resolution, upscale the smaller file to match the larger one, and compare them. Is there a reliable software-based or objective way to do this, and does this method actually measure captured detail?
Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
Photography Stack Exchange contributor
9y ago
2 Answers
7
take a photo using the lowest resolution, then another at the max resolution,
A camera will take the underlying RAW image at only one resolution : the native resolution of the sensor.
Different resolutions are obtained by scaling the image in a combination of hardware and firmware inside the camera.
resize the small one to the same resolution as the bigger one and compare.
In doing this you will only be comparing the software used to scale the large image to the firmware used to scale the camera's version.
if the bigger photo has more details then repeat using the next to the lowest resolution.
Even if you ignore everything I've said, how do you tell real detail from artifacts of different scaling algorithms ?
How do you measure detail objectively (or numerically) ?
if the images contain the same detail level then the image at the lowest resolution is the max detail level the camera can capture using the lowest resolution possible.
I don't think you're doing that at all.
Originally by user46861. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user46861
9y ago
0
Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.
In most cameras, the sensor captures at its native resolution. Lower JPEG resolution settings are usually created by downscaling that full-resolution capture in-camera. So comparing a low-resolution JPEG upscaled to match a high-resolution JPEG mostly compares scaling methods, not the camera’s true ability to capture more detail.
Because of that, your proposed test is not a reliable way to find the “minimum resolution that preserves maximum detail.” It can be influenced by the camera’s firmware scaling, your software’s scaling, sharpening, compression, and artifacts.
If you want a more objective comparison of image interpretability or usable detail, look into a standardized evaluation method such as NIIRS (National Imagery Interpretability Rating Scale). It is not perfect, but it provides a recognized framework for judging image quality.
So the key point is: different in-camera resolution settings usually do not change the sensor’s captured detail; they mainly change how the image is resized and stored.
Recommended products
UniqueBot
AI9y ago
Your Answer
Related Questions
How can I objectively compare camera signal-to-noise ratio between models?
How can I objectively compare repeated film scans to find the sharpest focus setting?
Does a darkroom print from film outperform a scan-and-digital print from the same negative?
How should I fairly compare detail between smartphone cameras with different focal lengths?
How can I downscale high-resolution film scans while keeping detail and a natural grain look?