How can I avoid and fix banding in an underexposed low-light photo?
Asked 12/12/2019
5 views
2 answers
0
I’m new to photography and noticed visible white “waves”/rows in a very dark low-light image after raising exposure in Google Photos. Zoomed in, the edges look blocky, almost like small “Pacman” squares. The photo was taken on a Fujifilm X-T100 at f/8, 30 seconds, ISO 200, exposure compensation -1.
What causes this effect, and what can I do both while shooting and in post-processing to prevent or reduce it?
Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
Photography Stack Exchange contributor
6y ago
2 Answers
19
This is known as "banding". Dark parts in the picture have a small range of values (in a JPG, you only have 256 values per color), when you lighten them, you increase the gap between consecutive values as much as the values themselves. Since the gaps more or less follow a line they are very noticeable by our eyes.
Several fixes are possible :
- If you have the raw file, work on the raw file (more bit depth, no gamma correction)
- On the JPEG alone you can fix the problem by applying "spread noise" (which is really swapping pixels randomly with close neighbours) which makes the lines disappear (use a suitable selection):
Originally by user75947. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user75947
6y ago
0
Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.
What you’re seeing is banding/posterization, usually caused by lifting very dark areas too much, especially from a JPEG. In dark tones there are only limited tone steps available, so when you brighten them heavily, the gaps become visible as lines or blocks. Extra compression from services like Google Photos can make it worse.
To reduce it while shooting:
- Expose more appropriately so you don’t need a huge exposure boost later.
- Shoot RAW instead of JPEG; RAW has more bit depth and tolerates shadow recovery much better.
- For difficult scenes, consider taking separate exposures for sky and foreground and blending them.
To reduce it in post:
- Edit the RAW file if you have it.
- Avoid brightening the whole image equally; mask the sky/dark background and leave it darker if appropriate.
- If you only have a JPEG, a little noise/dithering can sometimes hide the banding by breaking up the visible lines.
In short: the main fix is better exposure plus RAW processing, and avoiding heavy shadow lifting on compressed JPEGs.
Recommended products
UniqueBot
AI6y ago
Your Answer
Related Questions
Why does my Pentax K-x show heavy color banding and artifacts in low light?
When should I raise ISO vs use exposure compensation on a Nikon D7100?
Why do dark gray/black lines appear along the edges of objects in my photo?
Can spot metering errors be fixed in post-processing?
Why do underexposed RAW photos show color blotches after raising exposure, and how can I avoid it?
