How can a DSLR shoot faster than flash sync speed with a mechanical shutter?

Asked 11/20/2023

10 views

2 answers

0

I’m trying to understand what very fast shutter speeds like 1/1000s or 1/4000s actually mean on a DSLR such as the Canon EOS 90D. I know flash sync is limited to about 1/250s because, above that, the second shutter curtain starts closing before the first has fully opened. That makes it sound like the shutter is exposing the sensor through a moving slit rather than opening the whole sensor at once. If that’s true, how can the camera still freeze motion at 1/1000s or faster? Does the sensor effectively take 1/250s to be scanned from top to bottom, with each part only exposed briefly? And if so, why isn’t the rolling-shutter distortion much worse?

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

2y ago

2 Answers

27

Let me add some images.

On a mechanical shutter, you have two physical curtains (A) that move when you take a photo (B). The shutter speed is the average time the gap is over a zone of the sensor (C). In this example is half (Yellow) of the sync speed (Green)

enter image description here

When an object is moving fast, (and you have sufficient light to capture the image) the shutter gap is narrower to leave less light passing through it (D), but the curtains move at the same speed. If the object is too fast (E) it will keep moving relative to the gap, leaving a rolling shutter effect (F).

enter image description here

The maximum sync speed is when neither of the two curtains is over the sensor, and it is fully open. You use this when using a flash. Opening the first curtain (G) and when they are fully open you trigger a flash to capture flash (H) and then the second curtain starts closing (I).

enter image description here

If you use a faster shutter speed than the sync speed with a flash, (O) this will only illuminate the open zone (P) with probably some exposure on the rest depending on the ambient light.

enter image description here

In the image (C), if your maximum sync speed is let us say, 1/250, as it is half the opening, it would be 1/500. If the gap is 1/4 it would be 1/1000 and so on.


Some electronic shutters have a similar rolling effect because of how the sensels of the sensor are processed or read (J).

enter image description here


Do fast shutter speeds actually work?

If your camera is working properly, yes, it would work if you have sufficient ambient or continuous light like sunlight. It would expose each zone of the image at 1/4000 of a second.

It will freeze the movement to some extent depending on the factors I mentioned.

Remember that a fast shutter speed is not only used to "freeze movement" but also to properly expose images, for example with large apertures for bokeh effects.

Additionally, there are HSS flashes, that basically make a "stream of flashes" so the duration of the stream is enough to cover the time the gap covers the sensor. Those can be used in combination of a fast shutter speed.

You need a large aperture for bokeh so you need a fast shutter speed (K). You need a flash to properly expose the subject (L) You use an HSS flash (M).

enter image description here

To freeze some other type of elements you need a studio setup.

Originally by user37321. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user37321

2y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

Yes: above the camera’s flash sync speed, a focal-plane shutter exposes the sensor with a moving slit. The curtains usually travel across the sensor in roughly the sync-time range, while the selected shutter speed controls how wide that slit is.

So at 1/4000s, the whole sensor is not exposed simultaneously. Instead, each point on the sensor is exposed for about 1/4000s as the slit passes over it. That short local exposure is what helps freeze motion.

The tradeoff is that different parts of the frame are recorded at slightly different times, so a mechanical shutter does introduce some rolling-shutter effect. It’s usually modest because the curtain transit time is fairly fast (around the sync-speed timescale), much faster than many electronic-shutter readouts.

That also explains flash sync: a normal flash burst is very brief and can only illuminate the whole frame evenly when the entire sensor is uncovered at once, which happens at or below sync speed. Above that, the moving slit would only catch part of the flash unless you use high-speed sync, where the flash pulses so the slit is illuminated throughout its travel.

UniqueBot

AI

2y ago

Your Answer