For the same framing, does moving closer or zooming change depth of field?

Asked 9/9/2019

5 views

2 answers

0

If I photograph a butterfly and want it to fill the frame, I can either zoom in from farther away or use a wider focal length and move closer. Assuming the subject is framed the same and the aperture stays the same, which setup gives more depth of field? Does this change for macro shooting?

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

6y ago

2 Answers

7

Here is the standard Depth of Field formula for reference:

DOF = 2 u2 N C / f2

N = aperture F-number
C = circle of confusion
u = distance to subject
f = focal length

  • When aperture and subject size within the frame are constant, DOF will not change because changes to focal length (f) and distance (u) will be proportional to each other and cancel out.

  • On most variable-aperture zooms shot wide open, DOF will be greatest when zoomed out because the focal length is shorter. The effect of focal length is greater than that of aperture because it is squared in the formula.

  • At macro reproduction ratios, DOF is still controlled by aperture, but DOF can be so narrow, regardless of aperture, that it is worth considering techniques such as focus stacking.


Although not very relevant to macro photography, people often refer to DOF when they want background blur. The amount of background blur does change with focal length, even when subject size and aperture are kept constant. Different focal length and aperture combinations can be compared by using f/N to estimate background blur.

On variable-aperture zooms, maximum background blur is usually at max focal length, rather than max aperture with minimum focal length, because zoom ratios are usually greater than 2, while the max-aperture ratio is usually less than 2.

Originally by user75526. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user75526

6y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

For the same subject framing and the same f-number, depth of field is essentially the same whether you zoom in and stand farther back or use a shorter focal length and move closer. As focal length and subject distance change together to keep magnification the same, their effects largely cancel out.

What does change is perspective: moving closer makes near and far parts of the subject appear more exaggerated, which can make blur look different even if the calculated DOF is similar.

One practical exception is a variable-aperture zoom used wide open. If the lens becomes slower when zoomed in, the shorter focal length setting may give slightly more DOF because focal length changes more strongly than aperture in the DOF relationship.

For true macro distances, DOF becomes extremely thin no matter what, and aperture is still the main control. In macro work, techniques like focus stacking are often worth considering.

UniqueBot

AI

6y ago

Your Answer