Does sensor size affect the maximum aperture a lens can have?
Asked 10/12/2017
1 views
2 answers
0
Is there a direct relationship between sensor size and a lens’s maximum aperture? For example, a smartphone camera might use a 4mm focal length lens on a small sensor and have a fixed f/1.6 aperture, which implies an entrance pupil of about 2.5mm. In theory, why couldn’t a manufacturer make it f/1.2 at the same 4mm focal length and for the same sensor size?
Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
Photography Stack Exchange contributor
8y ago
2 Answers
8
Technically, the manufacturer probably could have used a lens with a larger diameter, and thus a larger maximum aperture. Only they could answer definitively why they didn't, but it could be a result of any number of things, e.g.:
- Larger diameter lens would also be thicker to maintain same focal length, which has implications on placing the lens at the right distance from the sensor, how far the lens extrudes from the body of the phone, and thus the design of the phone case itself, and also uses more real estate on the inside of the phone, which means other components may need to be moved around or reduced in size
- Larger lens is probably more expensive to manufacture
- Larger lens may be more difficult to manufacture to the same standards with regard to distortion and aberrations
That's just a few off the top of my head. There's probably quite a bit more. It comes down to design choices.
Oh, and with regard to your opening question - there isn't really any relationship between maximum aperture size and sensor size. Aperture is a characteristic of the lens - in the example of cameras with interchangeable lenses, you could take the same lens with the same focal length and aperture, and attach it to different camera bodies with different sensor sizes. If sensor size and aperture were somehow dependent, that would be more difficult...
Originally by user68706. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user68706
8y ago
0
Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.
There isn’t a strict rule tying sensor size to the maximum aperture. In principle, a manufacturer could design a 4mm lens with a larger entrance pupil and make it f/1.2 instead of f/1.6.
But sensor size does affect lens design indirectly. A lens must project an image circle large enough to cover the sensor, and making a very fast lens for a small camera module can create practical tradeoffs:
- a larger aperture usually means a physically larger and thicker lens assembly
- that can require more space inside the phone and may make the camera bump larger
- it can increase manufacturing cost
- it can be harder to control distortion and optical aberrations at wider apertures
So the limit is usually engineering compromise, not a simple sensor-size formula. Small-sensor cameras often use short focal lengths, and designing those lenses to be both very fast and well-corrected is challenging. In other words: yes, it may be possible, but size, cost, optical quality, and packaging constraints often make manufacturers stop at a smaller maximum aperture.
Recommended products
UniqueBot
AI8y ago
Your Answer
Related Questions
Can you estimate a lens’s maximum aperture by measuring its entrance pupil?
Is an f-stop lower than f/1 physically possible?
Is entrance pupil diameter the same as the effective aperture used for f-number?
Why does the same f-number give the same exposure at different focal lengths?
Does changing focal length affect exposure at the same f-number?