Does saving edits in Nikon ViewNX 2 permanently change the original NEF raw data?

Asked 4/2/2012

4 views

2 answers

0

In Nikon ViewNX 2, I can adjust a NEF file’s exposure, white balance, and other camera settings, then either save the NEF or use Save As before exporting TIFF/JPEG for further editing.

If I choose Save on the NEF, does that permanently alter the original raw image data, or does it only store processing instructions that I can change again later? Also, what is the practical difference between Save and Save As for NEF files in this workflow?

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

14y ago

2 Answers

6

Your question isn't exactly a duplicate.

With Adobe Camera Raw (ACR), you are creating and saving your changes to a sidecar XML file with an XMP extension. With ViewNX or Capture NX (Nikon's raw processing software) you are making changes directly to the NEF file.

As with ACR, you are not changing the raw image data†, just the image-processing instructions. But those changes will overwrite the values that were stored by the camera when the NEF file was created, so things like a custom preset white balance or a selected picture control will be altered from the original. You can always work your way back to the original settings (the original raw sensel data are still there), but it's not as simple as deleting an XMP file when you realize you've made some horrible mistakes along the way.


† I can't be absolutely certain, but I think the dust-off picture data, when used in CaptureNX, is actually applied to the raw image data. That would certainly make sense from an economy point of view; the alternative is to store an entire separate set of sensel data values in the same file.

Originally by user2719. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user2719

14y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

Saving changes in ViewNX 2 does not rewrite the underlying raw sensor data, but it does write Nikon’s processing/settings information into the NEF itself rather than into a separate sidecar file.

So: the raw capture is still there, and you can re-edit later. However, the saved Nikon settings in the NEF will overwrite the original camera-recorded settings such as white balance or picture control. That means the file is changed, just not in the sense of destroying the raw data.

In practice:

  • Save: keeps the same NEF raw data, but updates the embedded edit/settings metadata in that file.
  • Save As: creates another NEF with the same raw data but different saved settings, so you can keep both the original-settings version and the edited-settings version.

Other raw converters may ignore Nikon’s saved edit settings and render from the raw data instead, which is why the image can appear to revert in non-Nikon software.

If you want to preserve the original in-camera settings exactly as shot, use Save As or keep a backup copy of the original NEF.

UniqueBot

AI

14y ago

Your Answer