Does converting a JPEG to PNG help preserve quality when editing Fuji JPEGs?
Asked 8/28/2023
8 views
2 answers
0
I shoot Fujifilm and often like the camera JPEGs for film simulations and features such as Color Chrome FX that are hard to match in Capture One. Sometimes I only need light edits like crop, perspective, or lens correction.
I was wondering if converting the original JPEG to PNG before editing makes sense, with the idea that PNG might “freeze” the JPEG quality and avoid further loss until the final export.
So:
- Does a JPEG > PNG > edit > PNG workflow offer any quality advantage for limited editing?
- If I edit a JPEG directly in Capture One, does that preserve the original image quality unless I re-export as JPEG?
Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
Photography Stack Exchange contributor
2y ago
2 Answers
9
I think your understanding is incorrect. Converting a JPEG to PNG doesn't magically aid in quality preservation as you edit an image. Essentially, when an image is opened in an editor, the filetype that the image had been stored as is irrelevant; you are simply dealing with pixels that each have a RGB value. (These are 8-bit values in the case of JPEG.) When you push these pixel values around (i.e. applying edits to the image), new RGB values are calculated for the pixels. It doesn't matter if the image was a camera-original JPEG file or a PNG file saved from that original, the RGB values are going to be the same.
The difference comes when the image is re-saved as JPEG. It's at that moment that lossy compression is applied for JPEG files, and that's where quality is theoretically lost. If you were to save as PNG or TIFF, no lossy compression is applied. (Personally I prefer TIFF – probably things have changed, but there was a time when PNG didn't support colour profiles.) Re-opening these 2 hypothetical JPEG / PNG files can result in different RGB values for some pixels. This loss in quality however, based on re-saving a high-quality JPEG file as a high-quality JPEG file, one time, is negligible. You won't notice it. Still, if you intend to apply further edits, it makes sense to save your file using an image format that doesn't apply lossy compression.
The big difference is between 8-bit and 16-bit files. When you push pixel values around in a 16-bit file (i.e. applying edits to the image), then new RGB values are calculated with more precision, and there's more "room" for gradation between colour values. Especially for editing, 16-bit images are more, let's say, "desirable" than 8-bit images.
This explanation is a simplification, but hopefully adds something.
Originally by user38159. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user38159
2y ago
0
Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.
Converting a JPEG to PNG does not recover or protect image quality in the way you’re hoping. Once the JPEG is opened, the editor is just working with the image’s existing pixel values; saving that same data as PNG doesn’t improve it or give you more editing headroom.
The main quality loss happens when an image is encoded as JPEG, and again each time it is re-saved as JPEG with lossy compression. So editing a JPEG in Capture One does not inherently degrade it while you work; degradation happens on JPEG export/save, not simply because you adjusted crop or perspective.
If you want to avoid repeated JPEG losses, do your edits and export to a lossless format such as TIFF (ideally 16-bit if your software allows) for intermediate files, then make JPEG only for final delivery. PNG is also lossless, but it offers no special advantage over TIFF for photo editing workflows.
If your goal is to preserve Fujifilm-specific looks as closely as possible, use Fujifilm’s own software such as X RAW Studio when needed.
Recommended products
UniqueBot
AI2y ago
Your Answer
Related Questions
Should you convert an 8-bit JPEG to 16-bit before editing?
How can I stack JPEG exports for comparison without adding more compression?
What JPEG export quality should I use in Lightroom to preserve the original quality?
Why does a Photoshop Difference blend show changes after saving a PNG if PNG is lossless?
Photoshop JPEG export: Save As vs Save for Web, and what should you keep for printing?