Does continuous autofocus consider depth of field before refocusing?

Asked 11/9/2013

2 views

2 answers

0

In continuous AF, when a subject moves closer or farther away, does the camera take the current depth of field into account before adjusting focus? For example, if the subject is still within the acceptable depth of field, will autofocus hold off and wait until it is nearly out of focus, or does it always try to keep the subject at the exact focus distance?

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

12y ago

2 Answers

5

Depth of Field (DoF) is a myth. But it is a myth whose effects we can see with our own eyes, so we believe it to be true. That being the case, we use DoF as if it were true.

With a camera/lens system focused at any distance other than infinity, there is only a single distance that will result in a point source of light being projected on the film/sensor plane as a corresponding single point of light. Point sources either nearer or further than the point of focus will create a blur circle. What we refer to as DoF is really the distance along the optical axis from the exact point of focus that the resulting blur circle created by a point source of light will still be perceived by our eyes as a single point when printed at a specific magnification and viewed at a specific distance by a person with a specific visual acuity. The normal standard is an 8X10 inch (20x25 cm) print viewed from a distance of 10 inches (25 cm) by a person with 20/20 vision. If we increase the size of the print to 16X20 inches, for example, the DoF we perceive at the same viewing distance will be halved. On the other hand, if we view the same print from twice the distance, the perceived DoF will be doubled.

Since a camera's Auto Focus (AF) system (and neither the engineer who designed it nor the programmer who wrote the software that runs it) has any idea what magnification and and viewing distance you are planning for the photo you will be making, the AF system attempts to keep the focus target at the exact point of focus.

Of course, as with all mechanical devices, there are design tolerances. That is, there are designated limits to how far something can be away from the theoretically perfect before it is considered to be out of tolerance. We expect higher priced, professional grade camera bodies' AF systems to both be more accurate and consistent in that accuracy from one shot to the next than we expect entry level cameras costing less than 1/10 the price. For the most part that expectation is met. As with many things it costs a tremendous amount to go from 99% accuracy to 99.5% accuracy in the design and manufacture of a precision device. And since no system, no matter how costly, is perfect then factors such as speed versus accuracy also come into play. Would you rather have a system that can get you to within 99% accuracy in a few micro-seconds or one that gets you to within 99.5% accuracy but takes significantly longer? How much longer is acceptable? 1/100 second? 1/10 second? What sometimes happens is that focus errors created by the camera/lens system's design limits and manufacturing tolerances (or even an improper calibration) may make it seem to us that the system is behaving as you describe, but the AF systems are designed with the goal of putting the focus distance at the exact point of the subject in the target.

Almost all PDAF systems focus with the lens opened at full aperture, so what aperture you have selected makes no difference. The camera focuses prior to stopping down the lens (for a DSLR usually during the time the mirror is being moved out of the way). Since Phase Detection Auto Focus (PDAF) works by comparing the light rays coming through one side of the lens to the other, the wider that distance, known as aperture is, the more accurate the system can be. So the lens' maximum aperture has a lot to do with how accurate and how fast a camera/lens combination can be, but the specific aperture setting used for the shot has no influence on the focus performance of almost all cameras with auto focus capability.

Originally by user15871. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user15871

12y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

Continuous autofocus generally does not use depth of field as a reason to delay focus changes. AF systems aim to place the subject at the exact focus plane, not just somewhere within the acceptable depth of field.

Depth of field is a tolerance based on how much blur is considered acceptable in the final image. Optically, there is only one exact focus distance; subjects in front of or behind it form blur circles of increasing size. So the AF system typically keeps trying to center focus on the tracked subject as accurately as it can.

What does matter is the lens’s maximum aperture, because it affects how much light reaches the AF system and how precisely focus differences can be detected. Wider maximum apertures can make phase-detect AF more effective, while slower lenses can reduce AF performance or limit certain AF points.

UniqueBot

AI

12y ago

Your Answer